Chattanooga: EPB finances fiber, Comcast strikes back in court

Wednesday, April 23, 2008


By:
Jason Reynolds

A lawsuit filed Tuesday by competitors won’t delay the EPB’s plans to offer telecommunications services to residential customers starting this winter, an EPB official said.

“I don’t foresee this holding up the cable service,” said Aldous McCrory, EPB vice president of legal services.

On Tuesday, EPB’s board of directors approved issuing $219.8 million in bonds to finance a fiber-optic upgrade to an electric system that’s the backbone for bringing fiber to home telecommunications services.

Article: Chattanooga: Ready to go head to head

Article: Chattanooga: Reshaping the telecom landscape

Article:Chattanooga: Power cutoffs decline

Article:Chattanooga: Lawsuit aids to halt EPB cable venture

PDF: EPB Complaint

Article: Chattanooga: Media control center takes shape

Article: Chattanooga: EPB eyes contract for meters

Article: Chattanooga: EPB seeking cable franchise

Article: Chattanooga: AT&T targets cable competitors

PDF:Average EPB bill

Article: Chattanooga: EPB predicts wave of disconnections

Article: Chattanooga: EPB rolls out TV in March

Article: Tennessee: Cable appeals EPB case dismissals

PDF: Stamped Notice of Appeal

Article: Reshaping the telecom landscape

Article: Cable customers being switched one house at a time

Article: EPB set to invest in telecom gear

Article: Judge dismisses Comcast lawsuit

PDF: Comcast lawsuit opinion

Article: AT&T plans cable rollout

PDF: Lyles Decision to Motion to Alter or Amend

Article: Judge will rule next week on EPB suit

Article: EPB directors OK $26.4 million fiber loan

Article: Chattanooga: EPB to lend itself millions

Article: Tennessee: Cable group seeks EPB suit rehearing

PDF: EPB Official Statement

PDF: TCTA Motion to Alter or Amend

PDF: TCTA Notice of Filing

Article: Chattanooga: EPB gets loan at 4.6% for telecom plan

Article: Chattanooga: EPB finances fiber, Comcast strikes back in court

Article: Nashiville: House approves AT&T cable deal

PDF: TCTA Statement

PDF: Comcast vs. EPB

Article: EPB tries to wrap up bond issue

Article: EPB broadband bill dropped after open meetings amendment pops up

Article: Judge dismisses EPB lawsuit

Article: AT&T bill begins moving in House

Article: Lawmakers say AT&T bill should promote cable competition

Article: AT&T cable deal to be unveiled

PDF: Summary of the revised Competitive Cable

PDF: Resolution

Article: Chattanooga seeks federal funds for fiber-optics

PDF: Order Received from Chancellor Lyle re: TCTA v. EPBC

Article: EPB workers installing fiber-optic lines

Article: Hamilton County Commission gives EPB tax safety net

Article: Council approves EPB loan

Article: EPB delays fiber bonds

Article: Telecoms compete EPB set to challenge Comcast for local customers

Article: EPB faces cable lawsuit hearing March 7

Article: EPB approves fiber financing

Article: Littlefield leans toward AT&T in state cable fight

Article: Davidson judge lets cable suit against EPB proceed

Article: Naifeh, Bredesen disagree on cable

Article: Case hangs over EPB bond issue

Article: EPB filing in case says fiber plan is legal

Article: AT&T, cable fight nears $11 million

Article: EPB not ready to finance fiber-to-home project

Article: Judge considers dismissing EPB cable suit

Article: Ramsey says concerns about AT&T plan 'cleared up'

Article: Cable survey results challenge EPB video plan

Audio: Hamilton County Commission agenda session -- Nov. 13, 2007

PDF: Cable Survey

Article: EPB asks court to dismiss suit over cable TV

Article: Dueling video

Article: Cable TV drama ready for new season in state Legislature

Video: Cable competitor?

Article: EPB broadband wins Council OK

Article: AT&T to press state for franchise authority as council prepares to vote on EPB plan

Video: EPB seeks cable TV customers

Video: Competing for Cable Customers

PDF: Study of municipal cable providers

Article: Cable TV industry sues EPB to block broadband service

PDF: TCTA EPB Suit

Article: Fuel costs push up TVA electric rates

Article: Tech companies give input on EPB fiber-optic plan

Article: Public supports EPB fiber proposal

PDF: Comptroller's report on EPB telecom venture

PDF: Letter from Memphis City Council chairman

Article: EPB seeks input on fiber-optic plan

Also on Tuesday, Comcast of the South filed a lawsuit in Hamilton County Chancery Court to block EPB from bringing fiber optics to the home.

“Our intention is to ensure that EPB complies with the Tennessee Cable Act and that Comcast be allowed to compete in a fair environment,” Valerie Gillespie, Comcast vice president and general manager, said in a statement.

EPB should receive the bond funds in two to three weeks, said EPB President Harold DePriest. The utility plans to borrow money from the electric system to launch fiber to the home and could issue the loan next month, he said.

Comcast’s lawsuit says that EPB’s capital expenses from launching the telecommunications venture should not be funded by electric revenues, nor should electric revenues be used to back fiber-to-the-home’s financial risk. In doing so, EPB is breaking state law, the lawsuit states.

That’s not true, Mr. DePriest said.

“We’re absolutely confident what we’re doing is legal,” he said. “We understand that Comcast doesn’t want competition.”

Comcast’s lawsuit also says EPB has an unfair advantage as a city-owned company with no competition and access to low-cost loans.

On April 14, a Davidson County chancellor threw out a similar lawsuit that had been filed by the Tennessee Cable Telecommunications Association, an industry trade group. The chancellor ruled that Nashville, where the suit was filed, was not the right venue.

The cable association is considering its options and has until May 14 to make a decision, said Stacey B. Briggs, the organization’s president and executive director.

Comcast is a member of the cable association.

The $219.8 million bond primarily will pay for the smart grid, a fiber-optic system that EPB officials say will allow them to better control the electric system, restore power sooner during outages and prevent theft of electric service. Part of the bond also will buy standard electric equipment such as utility poles and transformers.

EPB now is installing fiber-optic lines to each of its substations as part of the smart-grid setup.

Subscribe Here!
Tech Talk