 |
|
|
| Gary Odom |
|
Georgians who thirst for Tennessee River water think they have found a “bombshell” supporting their legal justification for moving the state’s border 1.1 miles north into the Volunteer State.
Meanwhile, Tennessee lawmakers said Tuesday they are getting more serious about the issue and will remove most “tongue-in-cheek” language from a legislative resolution that would reject Georgia efforts to revisit a disputed 1818 boundary survey.
The ongoing “border war” has pitted lawmakers in both states against each other for weeks, generating national headlines, jokes, stunts and, increasingly, a tone of seriousness. Facing a historic drought and rapid population growth in Atlanta, Georgia lawmakers’ seek to move the border north so it would take in a portion of the Tennessee River at Nickajack Lake in Marion County.
Georgia state Sen. David Shafer, R-Duluth, who sponsored a resolution that would create a border commission to resurvey and reset the boundary at the 35th parallel, now argues that “Tennessee’s own ratification of the 1818 survey is invalid.”
“It was made subject to Georgia also ratifying the survey line, which never happened,” Sen. Shafer said.
“Georgia has repeatedly objected” to the survey line, and “on at least three occasions, Tennessee itself has acknowledged the line must be corrected,” he said.
Tennessee’s 1819 resolution defines the border as marked by Georgia mathematician James Camak. But it required Georgia to ratify a “similar” border before Tennessee’s measure took effect. Georgia never did that in its own resolution at the time.
Some historians and surveyors, however, are not so sure about Sen. Shafer’s argument.
“No. 1, it’s a moot issue with the length of time ... the border has been marked at the (current) boundary,” said Greg Spies, a surveyor and assistant professor at Troy University in Alabama who has researched and published articles on the dispute.
“If it’s not moot, when Georgia ratified the Alabama boundary, it in effect ratified the 1818 survey,” Mr. Spies said. “I think they’re kind of grasping at straws.”
Questioning Tennessee’s ratification of its own border language is nothing new. University of Georgia professor E. Merton Coulter in a 1951 “Georgia Historical Quarterly” article noted Georgia never met Tennessee’s requirement of ratifying a “similar” border.
However, he also concluded Georgia’s lack of a boundary challenge, despite knowledge that Mr. Camak questioned it in 1826 while surveying the Alabama-Georgia border, was as good as giving up all rights to the land.
In fact, Georgia ratified the Alabama-Georgia border, which leaves the Tennessee-Georgia border at the 1818 Camak calculation, even after Mr. Camak’s notification of doubts, Mr. Coulter concluded.
Article: Georgia water plan discussions begin
Article: Chattanooga: Area back on drought map following dry February
Article: Chattanooga: Record rains bring down drought-stressed trees
Article: Tennessee: Rain pulls much of region from drought designation
Article:Drought outlook brightens
Article:Drought not going away
Article: Chattanooga: Recent rains bring downgraded drought ratings
Article:Tennessee: Wet winter may battle drought/
Article:Dade County: Water restrictions vary, drought continues
Article: Georgia may tighten water restrictions again
Article: Drought outlook brightens
Article: Atlanta: 3 southern resevoirs predicted to fall
Article: Water authority begins planning
PDF: North Georgia water supply study
Article: Perdue backs border battle over water
Article: Drought persists in Dalton
Article: Dalton: Carpet industry works to save water
Article: Moving the state line won’t move water, Kiwanians told
Article: Nashville: Water plans to assist state not combat Georgia
PDF: Amendment No. 1 to SB3044
Article: Bredesen signs Georgia border resolution
Article:
Berke warns of long fight with Georgia over water
PDF: House Joint Resolution 919
Video: Water issues discussed
Article:
North Georgia officials dislike new water restrictions law
Article:
Drought dries up TVA income
Article:
Lawmakers hand Perdue border war
Article:
Georgia abandons border commission, not boundary dispute
Article: Resolution rejecting Tennessee-Georgia boundary commission moves in Senate
PDF: PDF: House Joint Resolution 919
Article: High hurdles with latest water bid
Article: Old stances on border dispute differ from today
Article: Tennesseans won’t volunteer for Georgia citizenship
PDF: 1972 Georgia Resolutions
PDF: Tennessee Legislations on Border Issue
Article: State House rejects Georgia border proposal
Article: Georgia already owns land in Chattanooga
Article: Water sharing gives Tennessee, Georgia towns perspective on border war
Article: Georgia lawmaker tries to grab Tennessee constituents
Article: Georgia questions 1818 border approval
Article: Georgia House passes water bills
Article: Perdue thinks U.S. knows Georgia water needs
Article: Littlefield says Georgia officials should consider other solutions to water woes
Article: Drought not going away
Breaking News: Littlefield says Georgia officials should consider other solutions to water woes
Article: Top court may see border dispute
Article: Georgia not the peach in battles with neighbors
Article: Georgia border proposal could cost Hamilton $2.4 billion
Article: Atlanta smacked by wet kiss
Slideshow: Give Our Georgia Friends a Drink Day
Article: Resolution criticizing Georgia border flap flows
DOC: Polk resolution
Video: Water Delivery
Article: Atlanta smacked by wet kiss
Poll: Should Chattanooga and Tennessee share water from the Tennessee River with Atlanta?
Blog: Shafer: Take Chattanooga water delivery “for what it is”
Article: Georgia lawmakers, reporters greet Chattanooga representatives on water journey
Blog: Littlefield sees off Atlanta-bound delegation
Article: City representatives head to Atlanta
Article: Georgia officials say facts, law back their claim to river
Article: Georgia lawmaker addresses Tennessee leader on water war
Article: Beware of Chattanoogans bearing gifts
Article: Tennessee draws line on border dispute
Article: Water conservation on tap
PDF: Tapping the Tennesse River at Georgia's Northwest Cornern
Article: Atlanta may only need ‘big straw’
Article: Tennessee, Georgia governors to cross paths, with water fight brewing
Article: Tennesseans say Georgia all wet
Article: Georgia lawmakers approve border commission to correct state line
Article: Tapping water resources now and for future
Article: Water plan opponents vow to change, strengthen it
Article: Senate panel passes bill calling for border commissions
Article: Border war talk is borderline silly, policymakers say
Article: War of words over water
Article: Border dispute not first between Georgia and Tennessee
PDF: Border Resolution
Article: Georgia legislators stir border war talk
Article: Rain levels above normal for the year, but area still in drought
Article: Gov. Perdue signs water plan, eases pool restrictions
Article: Georgia lawmakers want Tennessee to share river
Article: Counties with water supplies seek restriction waivers
Article: Monteagle rest area shutdown has mixed impact
Article: Monteagle reservoir situation improves, but fears persist
Article: Drought impacts livestock
Article: Drought drains Allatoona
Article: Anglers away
Article: Water tug-of-war
Article: Ga., Ala., Fla. governors talk water sharing
Article: Mayors say water relief is coming
Article: Plumbers help Orme conserve water
Article: Following prayers, Georgia gets rain
Article: One of three water supplies to Monteagle to be cut
Article: Bradley-McMinn water plan can be example, officials say
Article: Monteagle gets special delivery of water
Article: Development, water shortages linked
Article: Monteagle seeks funds for water
Article: Drought boosts well drillers
Article: Rossville chooses to conserve water though using Tennessee River
Article: Bredesen opposes river transfers
Article: Georgia gets temporary water supply boost
Article: Perdue seeks water compromise with Florida, Alabama governors
Article: Utilities importing supplies as historic drought persists
Article: Searching for a water resource
Article: Chattanooga touts its 'liquid assets' to industries
Article: Wanted: Water
PDF: Testimony of Ken Givens, Commissioner
Last month, the Georgia House and Senate each passed a separate resolution that would set up a commission to resurvey the boundary and set it at the 35th parallel, which Georgia maintains is the true boundary.
In Tennessee on Tuesday, House Majority Leader Gary Odom, D-Nashville, moved House Joint Resolution 919 dealing with the matter through the State and Local Government Committee. Sixty-eight of 99 House members have signed on as co-sponsors of the measure.
Rep. Vince Dean, R-East Ridge, who is among the co-sponsors, told Rep. Odom that “if Georgia were successful, I might be serving in the Georgia state legislature in a couple of years because it would take my house.”
But Rep. Dean noted, “I don’t take this as a tongue-in-cheek matter, and I would have been a little more comfortable if some of the wording might have been a little bit different.”
Replied Rep. Odom, “I understand; we’re working on that.”
The main intent of the resolution is to “simply say we’re not going to participate in this boundary commission because we don’t believe there’s a problem,” Rep. Odom said.
In its current form, the resolution mentions that “long-term possession of real property trumps survey boundaries” and cites several U.S. Supreme Court rulings involving boundary disputes that the state believes are beneficial to its case.
The resolution also states that “pertinent” legal precedent favors Tennessee “just as good fortune often smiles upon the righteous.” It also accuses Georgia lawmakers engaging in an “election-year ploy” for the “benefit of water-starved Atlanta, which is either unable or unwilling to control its reckless urban sprawl.”
That type of language may need to go, Rep. Odom said later.
Sen. Shafer said he remains “hopeful that Tennessee will appoint boundary line commissioners of its own and begin a neighborly discussion to resolve this matter.”
Post a comment
Commenting requires registration.