published Friday, August 21st, 2009

Cost of annexation 'essentially a wash,' mayor says

by Cliff Hightower
Audio clip

Dan Johnson

  • photo
    File photo

A projected $2 million in tax revenue collection per year from the proposed annexation areas would cover any costs to the city for additional fire, police, code inspectors and public works employees, Mayor Ron Littlefield said Thursday.

"It's essentially a wash," Mr. Littlefield said.

The city has looked at operational costs and they would be around the same numbers as the new $2 million coming in, the mayor said.

As far as capital costs, Mr. Littlefield said the city will need to add three additional fire stations, costing $1.5 million each, in Hixson, Lookout Valley and East Brainerd. The cost of equipping those fire halls would be between $500,000 to $900,000 each, city officials said.

The fire halls are needed anyway, Mr. Littlefield said, and the costs will be covered by city bonds.

He also said the city would need between two to three additional code inspectors, one more garbage truck and one more recycling truck.

But an opponent to annexation said Thursday the math "just doesn't add up."

"That's the fuzziest math I've seen," said Kyle Holden, president of Hamilton County Residents Against Annexation. "Even without the garbage trucks and additional people, it's $6 million."

Under Mr. Littlefield's numbers, 100 percent of the taxes from the annexed areas would be devoted for three years to paying for fire stations alone, he said.

Scott Bishop, an opponent to annexation who lives in Stonewall Farms, said he thinks the city is clueless about the costs.

"They really don't know how much this is going to cost," he said. "I can't stress that enough."


Dan Johnson, chief of staff for Mayor Ron Littlefield, said the numbers constantly fluctuate as more information comes in about the proposed annexed areas and the city learns more about what improvements need to be made such as street lighting, fire hydrants and road improvements.

"We're running numbers all the time and that's a work in progress," he said.

Much of the operational costs can be covered by the city's current level of service, Mr. Johnson said.

For example, two fire companies in Lookout Valley can be split, he said. The city is still studying how to put personnel in the Hixson and East Brainerd areas, he said.

Mr. Littlefield said there would be start-up costs after the annexations, but the communities annexed will grown over time, which means additional tax revenue, especially in areas near Volkswagen like Ooltewah.

As an example, the mayor pointed to the Ramsgate development, which used to be a pig farm. Now it is a high-end subdivision with sewers, he said. If the city puts in more infrastructure, it will only mean more revenue, he said.

"Investing in sewers and infrastructure is the best way we can go," he said.

Those sewers also are paid for by user fees and not tax dollars, he said. So, the city would be able to get bonds for any improvements and expansion and pay the bonds back from the user fees, he said.


Councilman Russell Gilbert said Thursday that he is worried the city will spread itself thin by using existing services.

While he hasn't seen a cost-benefit analysis from the mayor's office, he said he does not think the projected $2 million in revenue would pay for all the costs associated with annexation. He listed road improvements, fire, police, garbage, brush collection as being essential and said the money received from the proposed annexed areas would be a "drop in the bucket."

"You need to take care of home first before you take care of anything else," he said.

Councilwoman Carol Berz said she has not gotten "a full picture yet," but also knows the figures aren't completed. But what she has seen looks similar to the mayor's portrayal of the cost of annexation, she said.

"I think they've got it down pretty close and it does look like a wash," she said.


* $2 million: Projected tax revenue from proposed annexed areas per year

* $1.5 million: Estimated cost for each of three fire stations the city plans to build to cover the annexed areas

* $500,0000-$900,000: Amount to equip a fire hall

* 3: Additional code inspectors that may need to be hired

* 2: Number of garbage and recycling trucks that need to be bought

Source: City of Chattanooga

Comments do not represent the opinions of the Chattanooga Times Free Press, nor does it review every comment. Profanities, slurs and libelous remarks are prohibited. For more information you can view our Terms & Conditions and/or Ethics policy.
captainrt said...

Any politician that backs this annexation plan needs to remember that real people live in these areas, the kind that vote. Welcome to the unemployment line.

August 21, 2009 at 8:14 a.m.
user_name said...

So if it is truly "just a wash" (and it isn' they really think we are that dumb?), then why annex at all? It will be 3-6 years before a break-even point is reached (assuming costs will not rise in those 3-6 years), and there was not even any mention of sewer in these numbers at all!

Isn't it convenient that there is just now a rush to get it done AFTER Littlefield was elected for his last term? They are rushing through this so quickly, you'd think they were trying to pass national health care reform! I say once the city proves it can do a good job taking care of what it already has, then annexation can be discussed. Even then, the people should have a say. If we wanted to live in the city, we would have bought in the city.

August 21, 2009 at 9:04 a.m.
una61 said...

Guess who's being taken for a bath!

August 21, 2009 at 9:12 p.m.
stewartpb said...

I don't believe the Mayor's office knows what this will cost. They decided to push forward with this before they had a clue about the related costs. That is fact. I see no reference to the ongoing costs to pay and equip additional police officers when the City expands.

There are no additional firefighters or police available to serve the annexed areas. There are no currently operating fire or police academies. You can't just pull these people out of a hat. The annexed areas will have to be covered with existing resources for at least a year and probably two. The police and fire protection that currently city residents have will be diluted since the area they need to cover will grow. The Police Chief has stated he can't cover what he has with what he's got. Its going to be worse. A lot worse.

August 21, 2009 at 10:07 p.m.
please login to post a comment

videos »         

photos »         

e-edition »

400 East 11th St., Chattanooga, TN 37403
General Information (423) 756-6900
Copyright, Permissions, Terms & Conditions, Privacy Policy, Ethics policy - Copyright ©2014, Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc. All rights reserved.
This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc.