published Tuesday, March 17th, 2009

Chattanooga: Prebul dispute embittered by attorney barbs

by Lauren Gregory
Audio clip

Prebul phone Call

The financial dispute between Chattanooga auto dealer Joseph Prebul and his brother-in-law, New York jazz club owner Danny Bensusan, is becoming increasingly contentious as their lawyers trade barbs in and out of court.

Following a Hamilton County Circuit Court filing last week in which Mr. Prebul alleged that Mr. Bensusan had maliciously changed the terms of a long-standing business agreement, New York attorney Gerald McMahon is firing back through the media on behalf of Mr. Bensusan.

Mr. Prebul’s attorneys have “knowingly filed a false pleading in court, for ulterior motives,” Mr. McMahon wrote in an e-mail to the Times Free Press, announcing his desire to file ethics complaints against Chattanooga lawyers Christopher Varner and Wayne Peters.

Mr. McMahon did not return calls seeking additional comment Monday. It was not immediately clear whether he had actually filed a complaint, since the case manager for the Board of Professional Responsibility of the Supreme Court of Tennessee could not be reached, either.

Mr. Varner responded to Mr. McMahon’s allegations in a written statement that indicated he and Mr. Peters plan to save their rebuttal arguments for court.

“We were shocked by what we consider to be reckless comments made by an out-of-state attorney who is not an attorney of record in the pending Hamilton County Circuit Court case, and we will respond to and address these comments in the appropriate legal forum at the appropriate time,” he said.

PDF: Prebul government sentencing memorandum

PDF: Prebul memo to dismiss indictment

Article: Prebul bankruptcy filing reveals grim financials

PDF: Prebul financial documents

Article: Court set to OK sale of Prebul Infiniti

PDF: Motion for contempt

Article: Prebul trustee says Chrysler in contempt of court

PDF: Motions for default and removal

Article: Prebul case now in federal court in Chattanooga

Article: Liquidation of Prebul items coming to close

Article: Gregory pursues Chrysler dealership

Article: Prebul facing criminal charges after federal indictment

PDF: Prebul indictment

Article: Tennessee: Debts small and large mounting in Prebul bankruptcy

XLS: Prebul Debts

PDF: Prebul Debt

Article: Chattanooga: Prebul car sales going to creditors

Article: Chattanooga: Prebul auto franchise rights sell for $900,000

Article: Chattanooga: New faces, locations for former dealerships

Chattanooga: Prebul dealerships, customers in limbo

PDF: Complaint

Article: Chattanooga: New federal lawsuit filed in Prebul dispute

PDF: Bensusan Exhibit 7

PDF:Bensusan Exhibit 1 thru 6

PDF: Bensusan Filed Complaint

PDF: Bankruptcy claim against Bensusan

PDF: Complaint filed against TSE Group

PDF: Compliant with cost of bond

Article: Chattanooga: Prebul dispute embittered by attorney barbs

PDF: Prebul Intervenors Motion to Intervene and to Amend Counter claim

PDF: Joseph Prebul's Motion to Intervene

PDF: Motion to Expedite

Video: Prebul released on bond

PDF: Motion to sell free and clear

Article: Chattanooga: 'People are still buying' says Prebul attorney

Article: Tennessee: Civil lawsuit against Prebul dropped

PDF: Court filings

PDF: civil case filed against Prebul AutoGroup owne

Article: Hamilton County: $5 million bond upheld in Prebul civil suit

Article: Hamilton County: Prebul cases intertwined, trustee says

PDF: Prebul legal documents

Article:Chattanooga: Prebul criminal case not yet to indictment stage

Article:Chattanooga: Judge rules Prebul AutoGroup can continue operations

PDF: Trustee Jerry Farinash’s motion to intervene in the Circuit Court lawsuit

Article: Chattanooga: Trustee seeks buyer for Prebul dealerships

Court order for Prebul

Prebul bankruptcy

PDF: Prebul lawsuit

Article: Prebul dealerships forced into liquidation

PDF: Prebul Infiniti

PDF: Prebul Automotive

PDF: Prebul Imports

PDF: Prebul Jeep

PDF: Prebul Motorcars

PDF: Prebul Motors

Both sides have agreed that Mr. Bensusan wired $15 million to Mr. Prebul over more than a decade and was expecting the money returned. They do not dispute that Mr. Prebul failed to return some of the funds when asked, and that he signed a document promising repayment of the $7.6 million he still owed.

Federal authorities arrested Mr. Prebul last month on 11 counts of wire fraud. Mr. Bensusan was the alleged victim in that case.

According to court documents, Mr. Prebul had fooled his brother-in-law into thinking he was investing money in an interest-bearing Chrysler account for him when, in fact, Mr. Prebul was using it to cover personal and business expenses.

Attorneys now are squabbling over whether the money transfers were considered loans or investments.

Mr. McMahon — who is not representing Mr. Bensusan in the Circuit Court case but lists him as a client on his Web site — released to the Times Free Press a recording of a telephone call between Mr. Prebul, Mr. Peters and Mr. Bensusan’s son, Steve Bensusan.

In the recording, Mr. Prebul tells Mr. Bensusan — who refers to his father by his first name throughout the conversation — that it was a former employee dipping into the money to help with cash-flow problems.

“It wasn’t known to me ... what funds were there,” Mr. Prebul said.

Mr. McMahon denounced that statement in his e-mail and said Mr. Varner and Mr. Peters both know that Mr. Prebul knew exactly how the money was being used, even though it wasn’t meant to be touched at all.

In the recorded conversation, Mr. Peters made it clear that he knew Mr. Prebul owed the money, but explained that it probably wouldn’t be possible for him to refund it immediately.

When Steve Bensusan informed him that Danny Bensusan needed $2 million immediately in order to avoid losses in a business deal, Mr. Peters responded by explaining that Mr. Prebul just didn’t have it.

“Steven, I don’t see a solution to it,” Mr. Peters said. “I’m just being candid, because I don’t want to mislead you all.”

But Mr. Prebul was doing everything he could to repay Mr. Bensusan before his arrest, according to Mr. Prebul’s personal attorney, Thomas Ray. Mr. Bensusan could have avoided the trouble of criminal and civil proceedings had he been more willing to compromise, Mr. Ray said.

Now, Mr. Prebul has filed a counter-claim asking for a jury to wipe the debt clean and order Mr. Bensusan to pay him damages for conspiring to have him arrested, according to Mr. Ray.

“Instead of continuing to work with my client, Mr. Bensusan chose a drastic course of action that sadly has the potential to cause additional losses to everyone,” he said.

Comments do not represent the opinions of the Chattanooga Times Free Press, nor does it review every comment. Profanities, slurs and libelous remarks are prohibited. For more information you can view our Terms & Conditions and/or Ethics policy.
please login to post a comment

videos »         

photos »         

e-edition »

400 East 11th St., Chattanooga, TN 37403
General Information (423) 756-6900
Copyright, Permissions, Terms & Conditions, Privacy Policy, Ethics policy - Copyright ©2014, Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc. All rights reserved.
This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc.