published Saturday, May 9th, 2009

Chattanooga: Prebul facing criminal charges after federal indictment

by Jacqueline Koch
  • photo
    Staff Photo by Angela Lewis Joe Prebul heads for a waiting car after an initial appearance in the Joel W. Solomon Federal Building and Courthouse in Chattanooga, Tenn., on Tuesday, February 10, 2009. Mr. Prebul, who has operated 11 car dealerships, was charged with defrauding a New York relative of $6.8 million plus promised interest from investing the money. He was released on a $2 million promise to appear bond pending a hearing in the southern district of New York.

Former Chattanooga area auto dealer Joseph Prebul will be arraigned Friday in federal court in New York on criminal fraud charges.

He faces forfeiture of his money and property after his indictment Thursday in New York on charges of wire and mail fraud.

Mr. Prebul, former president of Prebul AutoGroup, is scheduled to be arraigned in a Southern District of New York court. He faces 11 counts of wire fraud and one count of mail fraud, according to a news release from the U.S. attorney’s office in Manhattan.

He must forfeit all property that came from proceeds of the wire and mail fraud offenses, according to the indictment. That includes, but is not limited to, at least $6.8 million and property at 401 Brady Point Road on Signal Mountain owned by Mr. Prebul, according to the city directory.

If neither the money nor that property is available, the government seeks forfeiture of any other property belonging to Mr. Prebul up to the value of the original property sought, according to the indictment filed by Lev L. Dassin, the acting U.S. attorney in the Southern District of New York.

PDF: Prebul government sentencing memorandum

PDF: Prebul memo to dismiss indictment

Article: Prebul bankruptcy filing reveals grim financials

PDF: Prebul financial documents

Article: Court set to OK sale of Prebul Infiniti

PDF: Motion for contempt

Article: Prebul trustee says Chrysler in contempt of court

PDF: Motions for default and removal

Article: Prebul case now in federal court in Chattanooga

Article: Liquidation of Prebul items coming to close

Article: Gregory pursues Chrysler dealership

Article: Prebul facing criminal charges after federal indictment

PDF: Prebul indictment

Article: Tennessee: Debts small and large mounting in Prebul bankruptcy

XLS: Prebul Debts

PDF: Prebul Debt

Article: Chattanooga: Prebul car sales going to creditors

Article: Chattanooga: Prebul auto franchise rights sell for $900,000

Article: Chattanooga: New faces, locations for former dealerships

Chattanooga: Prebul dealerships, customers in limbo

PDF: Complaint

Article: Chattanooga: New federal lawsuit filed in Prebul dispute

PDF: Bensusan Exhibit 7

PDF:Bensusan Exhibit 1 thru 6

PDF: Bensusan Filed Complaint

PDF: Bankruptcy claim against Bensusan

PDF: Complaint filed against TSE Group

PDF: Compliant with cost of bond

Article: Chattanooga: Prebul dispute embittered by attorney barbs

PDF: Prebul Intervenors Motion to Intervene and to Amend Counter claim

PDF: Joseph Prebul's Motion to Intervene

PDF: Motion to Expedite

Video: Prebul released on bond

PDF: Motion to sell free and clear

Article: Chattanooga: 'People are still buying' says Prebul attorney

Article: Tennessee: Civil lawsuit against Prebul dropped

PDF: Court filings

PDF: civil case filed against Prebul AutoGroup owne

Article: Hamilton County: $5 million bond upheld in Prebul civil suit

Article: Hamilton County: Prebul cases intertwined, trustee says

PDF: Prebul legal documents

Article:Chattanooga: Prebul criminal case not yet to indictment stage

Article:Chattanooga: Judge rules Prebul AutoGroup can continue operations

PDF: Trustee Jerry Farinash’s motion to intervene in the Circuit Court lawsuit

Article: Chattanooga: Trustee seeks buyer for Prebul dealerships

Court order for Prebul

Prebul bankruptcy

PDF: Prebul lawsuit

Article: Prebul dealerships forced into liquidation

PDF: Prebul Infiniti

PDF: Prebul Automotive

PDF: Prebul Imports

PDF: Prebul Jeep

PDF: Prebul Motorcars

PDF: Prebul Motors

Each fraud count carries a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison and a maximum fine of either $250,000 or twice the gross gain or loss from the offense, whichever is greater.

Mr. Prebul’s attorney in the New York criminal case, Roland Riopelle, did not return calls Friday seeking comment.

Mr. Prebul was arrested in February in Chattanooga in a criminal complaint for allegedly defrauding his brother-in-law out of $7 million. He then was forced to file for bankruptcy protection and liquidate all his dealerships.

A criminal complaint is a sworn affidavit investigators can present to a judge as a document for charging someone without going through a grand jury.

Mr. Prebul said in recent civil court filings that his brother-in-law, Danny Bensusan, conspired to have him arrested because he couldn’t immediately make a loan payment.

Mr. Bensusan filed a $32 million lawsuit against Mr. Prebul in Circuit Court in Hamilton County on Feb. 12. He withdrew that and filed another civil lawsuit in federal court in New York through New York attorney Gerald McMahon, but a judge has allowed Mr. Prebul to keep the Circuit Court case going.

From 2004 through December 2008, Mr. Prebul allegedly solicited Mr. Bensusan and others to invest money in a cash management program that he said would earn an above-average interest rate of return, according to the indictment. But instead of earning interest, the money was deposited in a Chrysler cash management account, where Mr. Prebul could transfer dealership profits.

“As (Mr.) Prebul well knew, the funds in the Chrysler CMP Account offset the amount of interest that Chrysler charged on the outstanding balance of a car dealership’s loan,” according to the indictment.

In July 2004, Mr. Prebul wrote to Mr. Bensusan’s son that “(there) is no better setup at any bank in America. It’s only for car dealers who borrow large amounts of money. If we are holding a large sum of deposit, let’s put the money to work and give us a great rate of return with no risk associated with the deposit. If you need it for operations, just call (an employee) and he can wire the money on the same day of the request,” according to the indictment.

The scheme allowed Mr. Prebul to obtain millions of dollars from Mr. Bensusan and his family through interstate wire transfers from a financial institution in New York, according to the indictment.

The money was not immediately available to investors because Mr. Prebul used it to finance business operations and to “fund a lavish lifestyle,” according to the indictment. But Mr. Prebul created false client account statements to maintain his scheme, according to the indictment.

The mail charge comes from a $500,000 check Mr. Bensusan mailed via Federal Express after false representations from Mr. Prebul caused Mr. Bensusan to mail it, the indictment states.

In July 2008, Mr. Bensusan requested about $6.5 million, of which Mr. Prebul returned $4.5 million. When Mr. Bensusan requested more and did not receive it, he demanded an accounting and a return of all invested funds.

Comments do not represent the opinions of the Chattanooga Times Free Press, nor does it review every comment. Profanities, slurs and libelous remarks are prohibited. For more information you can view our Terms & Conditions and/or Ethics policy.
please login to post a comment

videos »         

photos »         

e-edition »

400 East 11th St., Chattanooga, TN 37403
General Information (423) 756-6900
Copyright, Permissions, Terms & Conditions, Privacy Policy, Ethics policy - Copyright ©2014, Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc. All rights reserved.
This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc.