published Wednesday, July 7th, 2010

Wiedmer: Kiffin comes through where NCAA needs to, for recruit’s sake

Lane Kiffin did something good Tuesday afternoon.

No, the above sentence does not contain a typo.

However belatedly, Kiffin released incoming freshman offensive lineman Seantrel Henderson from his national letter of intent, freeing the nation’s top O-line prospect to play for any school he chooses in the upcoming season.

Because Henderson had signed a national letter to play for Southern California’s Trojans, Kiffin could have required the 6-foot-7, 295-pound Minnesota native to report to USC or pay his own way elsewhere and sit out the season.

In a rare sign of decency and character, Kiffin instead released the player without limits — USC could also have prevented Henderson from signing with certain schools — in the wake of the Trojans’ recent NCAA probation and two-year bowl ban.

“Seantrel has been great through the whole process,” Kiffin said, “and we wish him the best of luck with his decision.”

That decision figures to be Miami, which was a finalist for Henderson from the start and apparently received a visit from the player over the weekend.

But it never should have come down to what Kiffin would or wouldn’t do, because the NCAA should never force a signee to attend a school that goes on probation after that player signs, as was the case with Henderson.

To show you how messed up NCAA rules are, current Trojans who are about to enter their junior and senior years can transfer immediately without penalty — and without USC’s approval — because the two-year bowl ban means they wouldn’t get to go bowling for the rest of their careers, even though they’ve already played in two of them.

Ironically, Kiffin’s former employer already has benefited from that rule, Tennessee snapping up junior defensive end Malik Jackson on Monday.

But an incoming freshman — on the slender fact that he would be eligible to go bowling his final two years (three if redshirted) — has no such options. Hey, Vanderbilt theoretically is eligible to go every year and the Commodores have gone to one bowl in the last 28 years.

“Absolutely they ought to free those kids up if they weren’t recruited illegally,” said recently retired Ooltewah High coach Benny Monroe, whose best player from a year ago, defensive end Jacques Smith, is expected to battle Jackson for a starting job at Tennessee.

“They should be free to go wherever they want to if that school’s put on probation and they had nothing to do with it. But what really needs to happen is for something to be done to the coaches, athletic director or school president who was in charge when the violations occurred.

“You look at Southern Cal and (head coach) Pete Carroll heads off to the NFL. Reggie Bush (the central figure in the investigation) is playing for the (New Orleans) Saints. I think there should be some penalty for him, too. I’ve heard they’re considering taking away his Heisman Trophy, and maybe they should.”

Smith politely declined to comment on the situation because UT coaches don’t allow incoming freshmen to conduct interviews.

But Ole Miss freshman and Walker Valley graduate Jared Duke strongly believes any player in Henderson’s position should be allowed to transfer immediately.

“It’s a tough situation,” Duke said less than a week into his second semester of summer school. “And maybe it should depend on how you were recruited. But I think (releasing them) is the fairest thing to do.”

It should be the only thing to do. This isn’t the same as a coach — Kiffin, for instance — leaving. Reasonable men articulately can argue both sides of that dynamic.

Referring to that long-held NCAA policy, Monroe always told Smith, “Sign where you want to go to school, not with whom you want to coach you, because coaches leave. It’s a business and the coach you sign with may not stick around.”

Kiffin, of course, didn’t. He went to Southern Cal, which soon went on probation, though not for anything its new coach did during his first few months on the job.

Still, the NCAA shouldn’t leave it up to Kiffin or any other coach at a probation-strapped school to decide which incoming freshmen are allowed to leave without penalty and which aren’t.

The NCAA should allow all incoming freshmen to transfer from programs placed on probation after they’ve signed but before they’ve played. In the words of young Duke, “That’s looking out for the players.”

And naïve or not, isn’t that what college athletics should be about?

about Mark Wiedmer...

Mark Wiedmer started work at the Chattanooga News-Free Press on Valentine’s Day of 1983. At the time, he had to get an advance from his boss to buy a Valentine gift for his wife. Mark was hired as a graphic artist but quickly moved to sports, where he oversaw prep football for a time, won the “Pick’ em” box in 1985 and took over the UTC basketball beat the following year. By 1990, he was ...

Comments do not represent the opinions of the Chattanooga Times Free Press, nor does it review every comment. Profanities, slurs and libelous remarks are prohibited. For more information you can view our Terms & Conditions and/or Ethics policy.
Livn4life said...

The NCAA sets its own rules then enforces them as it sees fit often overpenalizing some and underpenalizing others. There seems to be no rhyme nor reason with the way they do things. If juniors and seniors have an option out so should sophmores and freshmen. But the NCAA does not consider that. The bottom line is this, if a young man does not wish to be at a school, even if he would be penalized, it will be to the school's advantage to give his scholarship to someone who does wish to be there no matter the probation situation. Since the NCAA refuses to see matters that way, universities can hopefully learn that it can be more detrimental to their teams and to individuals who are made to stay when they wish to be elsewhere. On the other hand, a commitment was made. It is a tough issue for Henderson and will be for others long after the USC time has been served. I do not know if saluting Kiffin is in order. They have purged the team from a potentially great player who might have been a distraction by lamenting being home during the first two post-seasons of his career. Who is really being taken care of here?

July 7, 2010 at 8:17 a.m.
87UTVOL said...

A good guy my foot. Check the SI website. Henderson has video of Kiffin telling him there would be no serious penalties by the NCAA. Kiffin's an outright liar or at a minimum seriously mislead Henderson. So much so, he had no choice but to give Henderson a full release.

Quarrel with the NCAA rule if you wish, but Kiffin doesn't do anything out of the goodness of his heart...not one thing. There may be a story about the unfairness of the NCAA rule as to USC freshman, but it does not start with "Kiffin Does Good Deed". Terrible reporter. Where's Rucker?

July 7, 2010 at 5:44 p.m.
87UTVOL said...

Okay Wiedmer, word is that USC linebacker freshman Glen Stanley wants out to transfer to a Florida school, but is getting stone-walled by Kiffin (see Orlando Sentinel). So, here's the challenge. Call Stanley. Call USC. Find out. Is USC going to extend the same graciousness you praise to Stanley? To any other player? Or, just to the one he lied to?

I expect to see a follow up story on these other players who, according to you, Kiffin ought to release. But, that won't happen. You got your story for the week, accurate or not. Move along.

Kiffin's a liar and you make him ought to be the good guy in this mess. Heck, he was on the staff watching Reggie Bush drive around a nice car, his parents travel to all the away games. Says Kiffy to RB Coach McClain, 'gee, how did Reggie get flush with cash?'. McClain 'Duh, I don't know. Maybe it was that job we got him with the sports agent's office'.

Awful, awful 'journalism'.

July 7, 2010 at 9:43 p.m.
WhitePineVol said...

NCAA..... Very much like the federal bureaucracy. Stupid individuals in charge. Lots and lots of red tape and unintended consequences. These idiots will spend $10,000 in man hours and travel expenses to try and find out who got a free hamburger. It's nuts.

July 8, 2010 at 10:45 a.m.
please login to post a comment

videos »         

photos »         

e-edition »


Find a Business

400 East 11th St., Chattanooga, TN 37403
General Information (423) 756-6900
Copyright, Permissions, Terms & Conditions, Privacy Policy, Ethics policy - Copyright ©2014, Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc. All rights reserved.
This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc.