published Sunday, May 15th, 2011

A haunted school system

Members of the Hamilton County Commission persistently neglect the public work their constituents need most — a county government with an urban charter, municipal-style ordinances, comprehensive growth planning and cost-efficient consolidated services and utilities. But they are all too happy to meddle in the county school board’s business and to use their budget clout to bend the school board to their agenda.

That was evident when the commission decided several months ago to withhold $7 million in payments-in-lieu of school fund property taxes for VW-related growth this year, pushing the school system’s fiscal deficit to nearly $14 million.

It was shamefully evident again last week when the commission’s political interference in the school board’s budget and administration finally led Superintendent Dr. Jim Scales to agree to a buyout of his contract this year, a year before it was to expire.

And it was blatantly punctuated by commissioners’ tasteless uniform advice to the school board, a day after Scales’ announcement, to replace Scales with a local candidate — i.e., Rick Smith, an assistant superintendent, and the white man they have wanted since before Scales, the merged schools system’s first African-American superintendent, was hired in 2006.

Meddling deeply rooted

The commission’s pressure and influence over the school board, though wrongful, flow from the era when county commissioners appointed school board members from their districts, and directed their patronage hiring clout, until the state established independently elected school boards in the 1990s. The commission’s influence remains strong, however, because county government holds the purse strings to funding for over a third of the school system’s budget.

In political terms, the commission’s interference in the school board’s work has long been led by Commissioner Fred Skillern and reinforced by his rising crop of disciples — Joe Graham and Chester Bankston on the commission, and his protégé, Rhonda Thurman, and her crowd on the school board.

Powerful political linkage

They now swing a majority on both the nine-member commission and the nine-member school board.

Thurman’s school board faction — reinforced in last year’s school board elections by the addition of David Testerman, Mike Evatt and possibly Joe Galloway — included chairman Everett Fairchild in the case of Scales. All have all been in accord on pushing Scales out of the superintendent’s slot. Their anti-Scales bias mirrors the earlier Skillern faction on the County Commission, which denied new school funding from 1999 until 2005 in the effort to force Scale’s predecessor, Dr. Jesse Register, to consent to a buyout of his contract. Register was subsequently hired to run the much larger Metro Nashville school system.

The linkage between the regressive forces on the commission and school board rests on their bias — originally Skillern’s bias — against efforts by Register, and maintained by Scales, to give significant focus to urban schools and the county’s large portion of black students.

That effort, including magnet schools, personnel shifts and the assistance of the Public Education Foundation, has been imminently fair and sorely needed. Urban achievement levels badly lagged those in the suburban, largely white schools that Skillern, a Soddy-Daisy resident, has favored since his stint decades ago on the old county school board, long before the separate city and county school boards were merged in 1997.

Skillern’s bias against magnet schools and a fairer urban focus, a cause Thurman has promoted since she joined the school board, has always been tinged by the sort of racism that long prevented the merger of the former city and county school systems. It was the clearly transparent reason for Skillern’s opposition to increased funding under Register.

Significant history

In the county’s 2004 budget hearings, for example, Skillern led a 5-4 vote to defeat former County Mayor Claude Ramsey’s proposal for a 56-cents tax increase for schools — a proposal patiently guided by Ramsey in a comprehensive, year-long school-summit process to build consensus support for a more adequate school budget. The defeat killed the summit’s momentum and recommendations.

Prior to that vote, Skillern had acknowledged that he had met privately with some of the commissioners, in violation of the Sunshine law, to woo them to his side, hosting them to a barbecue at his home to win their support. When asked by this page’s editor after the budget vote, and in front of Ramsey in the rotunda at the county courthouse, why he had not also invited the three black members then on the commission to his house to discuss the tax increase, he said with a laugh that he didn’t think he could “cook barbecue like them n------.”

His offensive remark reflected the racism that had long been evident in the division of school funds and resources prior to the merger of the two former school systems. That racism still seems to taint the opposition of some commissioners and school board members to the way staffing, curriculum and programs have been designed under the two superintendents who have presided since the merger.

Magnet schools, minority-to-majority school transfers, pre-school and after-school initiatives and a focus on improving school services and training serve a valid purpose in mitigating the educational and social issues that hinder minority students. Yet some commissioners and school board members seem all-too-willing to jettison such programs without regard for the disparate impact on minorities.

Effects of latent racism

It might be unfair to broadly assign racism per se to the animus among certain commission and school board members toward Register and Scales and some of the initiatives they have nurtured. Yet the signs suggest a latent racism that cannot be overlooked.

To put a halt to that, commissioners should pledge, at last, to take a hands-off approach to the school board’s business, and allow the independent board to pick a new superintendent without their insider meddling. That’s probably too much to hope for. But if commissioners turned their energy to broader initiatives for a charter and the creation of a forward-looking urban county government, they might become absorbed in larger goals, and finally realize the need an inclusive school system that serves all students equally well.

Comments do not represent the opinions of the Chattanooga Times Free Press, nor does it review every comment. Profanities, slurs and libelous remarks are prohibited. For more information you can view our Terms & Conditions and/or Ethics policy.
rosebud said...

You're saying Skillern said the n-word to you and Claude Ramsey, right Harry? I sure hope you've got proof. I smell a lawsuit.

May 15, 2011 at 11:18 a.m.
yaffay said...

The county commissioners, especially Skillern, seem to laugh in the face of the Sunshine law time and time again. Yet the people of Soddy Daisy continue to elect him to office. If Skillern used that term in referring to some of his fellow commissioners, it speaks volumes about his true feelings towards a significant portion of the citizens of Hamilton County.

May 15, 2011 at 1:47 p.m.
sandyonsignal said...

OMG. Glad you wrote this piece. Skillern needs to go. Blatant racist. We don't need an Archie Bunker wanna be running and ruining our County.

May 15, 2011 at 6:33 p.m.
sandyonsignal said...

Skillern needs to resign. He reflects poorly on the people of Hamilton County.

May 15, 2011 at 8:55 p.m.
ibshame said...

" in front of Ramsey in the rotunda at the county courthouse, why he had not also invited the three black members then on the commission to his house to discuss the tax increase, he said with a laugh that he didn’t think he could “cook barbecue like them n------.”

If this is a true account of what Skillern said, why has it not been made public before now??? It should have been made public a long time ago. Why did he even feel comfortable making such a statement? Was it because he thought no one in the group was ever going to say anything to the Black Commissioners? If William Cotten was one of the three Black Commissioners at the time, do you realize how long ago this statement was made and how long it's been undercover? Why?

May 16, 2011 at 8:51 a.m.
sandyonsignal said...

Just speculating, but my guess is there was a different publisher at the TFP. Tom Griscom was a speech writer for Ronald Reagan and well known partisan.

May 16, 2011 at 9:39 a.m.
ibshame said...

Supposedly the County Commission is going to be asked to fund Dr. Scales' contract buyout. Does Mr. Skillern plan to hold another Barbeque for certain Commissioners to discuss the buyout option and Dr. Scales' replacement? Maybe the five members of the school board who want the buyout funded by the County Commission will be invited to attend the next rib smacking session. Skillern and Thurman are like the Civil War Re-enacters for the South. Unfortunately for the Confederate Re-enactors the outcome is still the same: on April 9, 1865, General Robert E. Lee signed a surrender, for most the war ended and the Union prevailed. Much like the outcome of the Civil War is the same so too is the vote which merged the City and County School Systems: The City surrendered its charter for the City Schools. No matter how many Barbeques, no matter how many Superintendents are hired( whether they are local or not),no matter how many secret meetings behind closed doors to discuss contract buyouts and increased funding for schools, nothing is going to change the historical fact that on July 1, 1997 the City School System ceased to exist. The Schools in the former City System became the responsibility of Hamilton County to fund and maintain. Skillern and Thurman can keep fighting the same battle but thankfully the outcome will not change, no matter who cooks the Barbeque.

May 16, 2011 at 12:58 p.m.
please login to post a comment

Other National Articles

videos »         

photos »         

e-edition »


Find a Business

400 East 11th St., Chattanooga, TN 37403
General Information (423) 756-6900
Copyright, Permissions, Terms & Conditions, Privacy Policy, Ethics policy - Copyright ©2014, Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc. All rights reserved.
This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc.