We can think of any number of legitimate, constitutional functions of the federal government. National defense and foreign relations quickly come to mind, as do some other tasks.
But we can find nothing whatsoever in the Constitution that makes it a federal duty to come up with guidelines for public school districts around the country to use to prevent cheating by schoolchildren. Unfortunately, that has not stopped the U.S. Department of Education from doing exactly that.
Of course cheating is a serious problem. No one disputes that. The state of Georgia, for instance, has had a series of damaging cheating scandals in recent months that involved apparently hundreds of teachers helping children cheat on standardized tests -- or at least failing to stop the cheating.
That and other types of cheating in schools rob children of the education they are supposed to be getting, and make the cheaters believe they can get good results without putting in the necessary effort. That attitude will do them serious harm as adults, when they will discover that they lack the skills necessary to obtain good jobs.
But as serious as cheating is, it simply is not Washington's responsibility to be developing guidelines to combat it. Constitutionally, matters having to do with education are clearly left to the states and to the people.
If Washington wants to fight cheating, it should first set an example: It should not "cheat" the states by usurping their responsibilities.
related articles »
The federal government has no higher constitutional duty than to safeguard the security of the United States.
As you may recall, under the debt-limit increase that Congress worked out, a 12-member "super committee" of Republican and Democrat ...
There is a high price to pay for inappropriately involving the federal government in public education, a duty that the ...
Teachers spent nights huddled in a back room, erasing wrong answers on students’ test sheets and filling in the correct ...
In a way -- a rather twisted sort of way -- it is the government's job...after all, they caused it. If it didn't reward the losers later in life for cheating themselves out of a decent education and a way to earn a decent wage, they wouldn't cheat...or if they did, they would have only themselves to blame.
Cheaters have been with us forever. Anyone remember the days of high school "bone-head" English and shop class for the losers? One thing, it allowed the rest of us to learn life-skills to earn our own way.
Or login with:
New Account