published Tuesday, October 23rd, 2012

5-at-10: Grading the SEC coaches, NFL power poll, sports top scandals

From the "Talks too much" studios...

SEC coaches

Follow the trickle down here: College sports is ruled by football. College football is ruled by the SEC. SEC football is ruled by elite coaches. Ergo, there is nothing in the game we love more important that coaching excellence.

We can all agree on that right? No questions? And we all agree that at $5 million, Nick Saban may be the best bargain not only in college football, but in all of sports, right? With that in mind, let's grade the SEC coaches, and compare them to a Clint Eastwood movie. Deal? Deal? (Side note: There will be two grades — the first for this year to date and the second for their time at the program)

Nick Saban — A+/A++++

Saban arrived in Tuscaloosa in 2007. Went to the SEC title game and the Sugar Bowl in 2008. Won it all in 2009 and '11 and is poised to do it again this year with the most complete team in college football. How good is Saban? Most of the rest of the SEC is resigned to the fact that the best way to topple his Alabama machine is for him to leave. So basically, Saban has made the SEC — the best college football conference in the country — WWII France, and everyone else is hoping he'll just go away to the NFL or something.

Eastwood movie: Unforgiven. Dude is a bad man, even teams that play Alabama tough and deserve a better fate need to remember, "deserve ain't got nothing to do with it."

Will Muschamp — A+/A

In his second year, Will Muschamp has done work. If the voting was held today, he'd be the SEC coach of the year and rightly so. A defensive guy with an elite defense, Muschamp and Co. get high praise for their handling and development of quarterback Jeff Driskel.

Eastwood movie: Fistful of Dollars. The super-power and uber-rich program that is Florida appears to be back (to be fair, 9er called from the get-go), and like Fistful of Dollars kind of started Eastwood's run, this looks like the genesis for Muschamp, who at the beginning of the season was an unknown with some provin' to do.

Dan Mullen — A/B+

If you think this grade is too high, ask yourself this: would you trade your coach for Mullen? Now know this: Mullen is an inspired and improbable upset of Alabama away from having Mississippi State in the national championship picture. Yes. Mississippi State.

Eastwood movie: High Plains Drifter. Mullen is doing work with the Bulldogs and appears to be content in Starkville (well as content as anyone can be that is). That said, here's saying his name will be bandied about for a slew of openings this offseason.

Kevin Sumlin — A-/A-

Sumlin has made the most of his left over strengths — having two NFL-ready tackles helps any offensive transition — and found a future star in his high-scoring offense with quarterback Johnny Manziel.

Eastwood movie: Sudden Impact. Sumlin and Manziel deserve big props for coming in and taking names from the get. Buckle up gang, Texas A&M is going to be a tough SEC hombre.

Steve Spurrier — B+/A

Spurrier's the man. He's so money. The bottom has fallen out the last couple of weeks, but name one team in this league other than Alabama that could lose its best offensive player for most of two big games and not be affected. His career A is well-deserved since he has reset South Carolina's records and goals.

Eastwood movie: There are so many, but we'll go with the Outlaw Josey Wales. Spurrier has always been infinitely quotable (our favorite remains when asked about the fire at the Auburn library he said, "It's a shame, too, because a lot of those books hadn't been colored in yet.") and excellent.

Hugh Freeze — B+/B+

Freeze has the Rebels eyeing a bowl game and out of the SEC West cellar. For a team that had lost 16 SEC games in a row until this year, that's doing working in year one.

Eastwood movie: For a Few Dollars More. You get the feeling that Freeze may be one more year from being "that" guy for a lot of programs.

Les Miles — B+/A

We love Les Miles. You know this. And his 'B' this year is as much about the Tigers' lofty expectations than any shortcomings this year, especially considering he had to suspend his best playmaker for the season in August.

Eastwood movie: Every Which Way but Loose. Underrated, tough and violent, and at times silly. Is there a better matching for an Eastwood film and an SEC coach than this? We almost went with the Outlaw Josey Wales because it's Eastwood's most quotable movie, and we all know that Les is supremely quotable.

James Franklin B+/B+

Franklin has Vandy on the cusp of history. The Commodores had a tough early schedule and survived it. They are 3-4 with a win on Saturday against winless UMass all-but-certain. They'll go into November with a manageable slate of at Kentucky, at Ole Miss, vs. Tennessee and at Wake Forest needing to split to qualify for back-to-back bowl games for the first time in program history.

Eastwood movie: Escape from Alcatraz. If Franklin, who was the head-coach-in-waiting, makes winning history at Vandy, he'll likely write his own ticket this offseason.

Mark Richt — B/B

Easiest grade on the whole board. Mark Richt is a good guy who is a good coach who has had a good career in Athens. The only question is whether that's going to keep being good enough.

Eastwood movie: Trouble with the Curve. Richt's grade was easy, the movie was not. We'll go with the touchy-feely new release (we haven't seen it) because the title fits Richt's career. If this were the 1990s and early 2000s, Richt's run would be more highly appreciated. Today, since the SEC has won six title in a row and the power-player that is Georgia is not among them, the SEC grading curve is steeper. And Richt's resume suffers because of it.

Derek Dooley — D+/C-

Toughest grade on the board for several reasons. As for this year, yes, the Vols' losses are to teams that are a combined 27-1. But, they looked ill-prepared after a bye week against Mississippi State. Yes, Dooley inherited a mess. But name one player on this team that has improved this season other than the offensive linemen (shoutout to Sam Pittman)?

Eastwood movie: Heartbreak Ridge. Every time we want to believe in Dooley and his Vols, they break our hearts and push us over the ridge. We almost went with City Heat because of the hotseat.

Gary Pinkel — D/B

The Tigers have been bad — home losses to Vandy are not acceptable even for newcomers — and the injury to quarterback James Franklin has been a big part of it.

Eastwood movie: The Gauntlet. Perfect right? Arguably the most forgettable Eastwood movie since he became a star for an forgettable season for the Tigers. But Missouri will realize the reward of running the SEC gauntlet when the roughly $28 million checks are passed out next May.

Joker Phillips — D-/D

Phillips improved his grade last Saturday. The Wildcats are cooked and Phillips is likely gone, but his team fought for 60 minutes against a superior Georgia team and that shows respect for the staff and program in general and the head coach in particular. That said, Phillips inherited a Kentucky program on the upswing and has turned its fortunes around.

Eastwood movie: The Dead Pool. The downward spiral in Lexington is as much about injuries (it seems like the Cats are on QB No. 2,305 and are one more injury from having a halftime drawing for some QB reps) and history (other than Bear Bryant, name one coach who moved up from the UK job).

John L. Smith — D-/C-

The interim replacement for Bobby Petrino endured a disastrous September. The Hogs had national title hopes, but will go to a low-to-mid-level bowl. It will be interesting to see where the Hogs set their sights for their next coach considering a) they had a head start on everyone else, and b) the off-the-field stuff is much more important in Arkansas' search this time around.

Eastwood movie: A Perfect World, a disappointing movie with a star-studded cast that started slowly and got better but still left you walking away feeling like it should have been more.

Gene Chizik — F-/C

This has been a debacle, and as we stand here we still don't believe Chizik should be fired. That said, Tuberville got got for better than this mess, and Chizik has to go to Tuscaloosa to end the year. Remember Saban sealed Tuberville's fate with a 36-0 spanking in 2008. This is Chizik's fourth year. If you look at 2009 as a B, 2010 as an A+, 2011 as a C and this as an F-minus, that leaves with an average bell curve, no?

Eastwood movie: In the Line of Fire. Title alone makes it match, but this is one of the best Eastwood movies and one of the few in which Eastwood is outperformed. The question is, is John Malkovich parallel Gus Malzahn or Cam Newton?


NFL Power poll

Time for our weekly check around the (cue Ron Jaworski) THE NATIONAL FOOTBALL LEAGUE.

(Side note: How cool would it be to hire someone with a renowned catch phrase to follow you around at a party or a tailgate and use their money quote. And if you could, who you got between Gary Coleman saying, "Whatcha you talkin' bout Willis?" or the Fonz using "Aaayyyy," or "Sit on it," or Fred Sanford using, "I'm coming Elizabeth" and "You big dummy.")

1) Atlanta: The Falcons are the league's lone unbeaten team. They are built for today's league — they can throw the ball (eighth in passing) and defend the pass (seventh in passer rating against) — and have a legit home-field advantage. We like the cut of their jib.

2) Houston: There are wins and losses and never the twain shall meet. There also are statement games, and the Texans delivered one with Sunday's 43-13 win over Baltimore.

3) Chicago: Holding Calvin "Megatron" Johnson to three catches is good stuff. Holding the Lions to seven points in better stuff. Becoming a Super Bowl contender with Jay Cutler at quarterback is big-time stuff. How underrated is Lovie Smith?

4) San Francisco: Yes, the 49ers defense may be a step better than Chicago's but the Bears' offense is two steps better than San Fran's.

5) New York Giants: The defending Super Bowl champs will be there until the end. This just in... those Manning kids are pretty good. Cue Fred — "You big dummy."


Game 7 letdown

Unless you're a San Fran Giants fan, Monday's Game 7 was a disappointment. So it goes.

But as we head to a World Series that will largely be skipped by most of the country, what can we glean from a Giants-Detroit Tigers showdown?

First, to be a contender you have to have a shutdown ace. The Tigers have Justin Verlander; the Giants have Matt Cain. (And before this season, the Giants actually were holding a pair of aces with Cain and Tim Lincecum, but that was before Lincecum caught a case of the stinky.)

Second, you need a middle of the order stud. The Tigers have Miguel Cabrera; the Giants have Buster Posey.

Third, you need a manager that can role with things and makes the magic happen. The Tigers have Jim Leyland; the Giants have Bruce Bochte (who is not to be confused with Bruce Banner or Bruce Boxlighter).

Finally, you need a few postseason breaks. The Tigers exploited a young A's team that gagged under the pressure and a Yankees team that couldn't hit its collective butt with either hand; the Giants got an epic performance from some cat named Marco Scutaro, who was the NLCS MVP even though he has a name made for Formula 1 racing.

What does it mean? Likely means Tigers win it all since Verlander can go three times if needed. But it's not like we'll be watching any way.


This and that

— In a polling of NBA GMs, the Miami Heat were picked to repeat as NBA champs. We can see that. And we are stoked to watch LeBron James play this year with the onus of winning a title off his back. Giddy-up.

— The SEC preseason hoops predictions from media members were released Monday. Kentucky was an overwhelming pick to win the league. That's not that surprising. Tennessee and Cuonzo "The Conz" Martin were picked fourth. The All-SEC first team was BJ Young of Arkansas, Florida's Kenny Boynton (who has been in school since 1989 — he was in the same recruiting class as Dwayne Schintzius we think), Nerlens Noel of Kentucky, Phil Pressey of Missouri and Tennessee's Jarnell Stokes.

— Rambo turned 30 this week. No not Sly Stallone — he's closer to 130. No, the "First Blood" movie that introduced us to John J. Rambo was released this week in 1982. Earlier this month we did the best movie trilogies. We'd have to give Sly Stallone the No. 2 spot on the list of actors with best multiple trilogies behind Harrison Ford. Well done Sly.


Today's question

Our question today comes from a post from Jomo on Monday:

"Jay- Lance Armstrong, Tiger Woods, Mike Vick, Joe Paterno, Kobe Bryant ( does anyone remember sexual assualt ), Mike Tyson, Ray Lewis ( involved in murder ), Barry Bonds, Roger Clemons, Pete Rose,

all falls from grace. Who goes on Scandal Rushmore ? is it based on endorsement ? public perception ? Ban from Sport ? or Who has made a comback ?"

We like this question enough that we brought it out of Friday's mailbag into the here and now.

Here's our serious sports scandal Rushmore (combination of serious crimes and sports stature): Paterno, Tyson, O.J., Vick

Here's our tabloid sports scandal Rushmore (combination of sports stature and overflowing voyeur interest in the case): Tiger, O.J., Paterno, Lance

Great question and feel free to participate.

about Jay Greeson...

Jay was named the Sports Editor of the Times Free Press in 2003 and started with the newspaper in May 2002 as the Deputy Sports Editor. He was born and raised in Smyrna, Ga., and graduated from Auburn University before starting his newspaper career in 1997 with the Newnan (Ga.) Times Herald. Stops in Clayton and Henry counties in Georgia and two years as the Sports Editor of the Marietta (Ga.) Daily Journal preceded Jay’s ...

Comments do not represent the opinions of the Chattanooga Times Free Press, nor does it review every comment. Profanities, slurs and libelous remarks are prohibited. For more information you can view our Terms & Conditions and/or Ethics policy.
Salsa said...

Dooley's grade will be changed to an F in Fired.

October 23, 2012 at 10:27 a.m.
John_Proctor said...

The Eastwood bit is absolutely brilliant. I might have substituted Dirty Harry for the Unforgiven (picture Coach Satan mouthing "Go ahead punk. Make my day) to any SEC coach you care to name but especially to John Reeves's son-in-law. I would pay money to see that happen.

As for quotes, nothing can replace the other Great Satan's sayings. "You can't spell citrus without UT" or "FSU-Free Shoes U." The infuriating part is that he backs up them up.

When it comes to the Mount Rushmore of scandals, there should be a place for the 1919 Chicago Black Sox Scandal. Don't know how that plays out considering the plethora of modern miscreants but those guys earned a place there even more than Charlie Hustle. YOMV.

October 23, 2012 at 10:45 a.m.
JonathanMCook said...

Okay, since this has not been discussed in the 5 at 10, I can tell my story based on JR's sports report on today's Morning Press from earlier today.

So I ran into this cute girl at my office break room who was wearing a UT golf shirt. So I asked her in my softest, sexiest, swave, bishonen voice, "Hey baby, can you show me your [p-word]"?

She smiles, unzips her pants, and whips out a picture of Tyler Bray.

::cue rimshot::

I like the Clint Eastwood/SEC coach comparsions. Could really careless about the World Series (for obvious reasons), and go Mocs.

October 23, 2012 at 10:54 a.m.
jgreeson said...

Salsa —

Quite possibly. It feels like it is swinging that way, doesn't it?

Johnny P —

Thanks for the kind words. And yes, you can bellyache all you want about Spurrier's quotes and commentary, but dude backs it up big time.

The Black Sox thing is an excellent call. Almost killed baseball, and sweet buckets of Buster Olney breakdown, can you image if that happened in today's 24/7 media circus?

Run JMC —

Careful. Remember this is a family-oriented, interweb-based sports column.

Nice job giving credit where credit is due, however.

— 5-at-10

October 23, 2012 at 11:14 a.m.
JonathanMCook said...

I know Jay. That's why I didn't use the actual word. But after hearing what he did post game, Dooley had every right to say what he did. So unfortunately, the Devil's writing staff tossed me that bone before they headed to work on Leno's show. :P

Glad you liked it none the less though.

October 23, 2012 at 12:18 p.m.
bigguy said...

What did the Alabama cheerleader say when she was having sex???

Git off me daddy, you're crushing my cigarettes!

October 23, 2012 at 12:47 p.m.
fechancellor said...

Your Clint Eastwood play, cue Mr. Burns (hands pented) "Excellent."

That said, Dooley merits an F for the simple reason he cannot get the most of the talent at hand.

Ten Ring writes: "Every time we want to believe in Dooley and his Vols, they break our hearts and push us over the ridge."

Dooley did take the high ground in the opener against NCSU. Where he was pushed off the ridge was after a fine first half against Florida. Since that game, the Vols have not stormed any redoubt or even defended their own.

I must say there's no confidence here at the enterprises in Dooley any longer, and you've have displayed even less, so it's hard to understand how Dooley can break your heart.

October 23, 2012 at 1:04 p.m.
jgreeson said...


Fair enough.

Bigguy —

That's the fundamental way we know Saban has us whipped. We're forced to use off the field jokes. (And yes, when we re-tell that one, we'll give you credit.)

FE to the C —

Thanks for the kind words.

And you make a fair point about continually getting your hopes up with Dooley. (Definition of insanity and all).

That said, maybe it's the traditional SEC fan in the 5-at-10, but we thought UT was going to play tougher just like we thought Auburn was going to beat Ole Miss and Vandy.

So it goes and welcome to the New World.

— 5-at-10

October 23, 2012 at 1:36 p.m.
WilliamRscott said...

Jay, A new poster, "Muddog", tossed 2 good questions your way at 8:35 last night. Maybe you can get to them later today or Friday. Looking forward to seeing you Mon Oct 29 at the QB Club lunch meeting. Thanks.

October 23, 2012 at 2:11 p.m.
chas9 said...

Does Rambo still play for UGA?

Great Eastwwd flicks links. Grades are perfect.

I just drove through Knoxville. Radio callers are talking Gruden, Mullen, Strong, Spurrier. Predictable. Guess they agree with your grades.

Bill Curry moved up from KY to Ga. State.

October 23, 2012 at 2:19 p.m.
fechancellor said...

Ten Ring, as you can see, I'm so frustrated with Tennessee that my despair spills sometimes upon unintended places. From such depths, I see little respite this year and probably the next.

October 23, 2012 at 2:32 p.m.
BIspy4 said...

5, where do you play Muhammad Ali's loss of his championship belts for his anti-war stance in the scandal Rushmore?

There is Bruce Bochte, former backup infielder for a variety of teams. And there is Bruce Bochy, former Astros and Padres catcher who is now manager of your National League champion San Francisco Giants.

It doesn't look like we'll get a Cain-Verlander matchup in the Series, which is too bad, because that has the potential to be a Smoltz-Morris Game 7 showdown type affair. And as much as I (and many others) loathe the Buck-McCarver pairing Fox has, it was really cool of them to replay Skip's audio from the 92 NLCS Game 7. "A double, a walk and an error, and the bases are full of Braves. Bream carries the winning run .... Two balls, one strike ... What tension ... the runners lead ... a lot of room in right center. If he hits one there, we can dance in the streets ... The 2-1 ...."

October 23, 2012 at 3:49 p.m.
chas9 said...

Dr. B said UT should hire Muschamp but they didn't listen.

October 23, 2012 at 4:37 p.m.
mcpell3 said...

Spy - my favorite braves game of all time.

Chas- I wish Auburn had hired him when they hire Gene - Coach Boom's D's were as tough as Dye's.

October 23, 2012 at 4:56 p.m.
please login to post a comment

Other National Articles

videos »         

photos »         

e-edition »


Find a Business

400 East 11th St., Chattanooga, TN 37403
General Information (423) 756-6900
Copyright, Permissions, Terms & Conditions, Privacy Policy, Ethics policy - Copyright ©2014, Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc. All rights reserved.
This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc.