published Wednesday, September 12th, 2012

GOP abuses voters' rights

This nation's historical march toward fairer elections may well be stymied this November by two deplorable phenomena.

One is the pending end-of-campaign advertising blitz that will be grossly warped by the expenditure of nearly a billion dollars by super-PACs and openly partisan non-profit entities funded by a handful of anti-Obama multibillionaires and megamillionaires. Under the Supreme Court's blatantly partisan 5-4 ruling in the Citizens United case in 2010 that airily overturned a century of high court precedents against unchecked election spending, this new wave of cash by super-rich individuals and corporate chiefs will be perfectly legal so long as its dirty campaign ads are not technically coordinated with the candidates' official campaigns.

The second phenomena is the wave of strict voter-ID laws adopted -- on the indefensible and unproved notion of voter fraud -- by Republican-controlled state legislatures since 2010. Their real purpose is to suppress the votes of the elderly, minorities, students and naturalized immigrants, whose votes in 2008 helped President Obama win the election.

Not much can be done in the short term about the cash sewer from the Koch brothers, casino czar Sheldon Adelson and their pals who are driving the financing of the super-PACs and the abuse of nonprofit -- and supposedly nonpartisan -- entities allowed under the IRS codes. Until the activist Republican majority on the Supreme Court is reined in, the super-rich now can influence close elections almost at their whim. Still, it is the harsh voter ID laws that are most vulnerable to legal challenges -- and that are most likely to tilt a very close election at the end.

There is, to be sure, a clear connection between funders of the super-PACs and the voter ID laws. The Koch brothers, for example, also help fund the American Legislative Exchange Council, known as ALEC. Which is the source of the "model legislation" that Republican-dominated Legislatures -- Tennessee's GOP lawmakers are on it like ticks on a hound dog -- have used to roll out extreme voter ID, gun-carry and anti-abortion laws, while quietly gutting campaign financing restrictions on corporate interests and lobbyists' campaign donations. Tennesseans who doubt ALEC's impact here need only examine the ALEC model bills our Legislature passed earlier this year. One of those bills went so far as to strike language referring to its "model bill" source.

Regardless, the strict voter ID laws yet remain subject to rulings from trial and appellate courts, and they should be challenged.

Elderly, minority and immigrant voters targeted by these laws often do not own cars or have readily available transportation to gather documents and take them to drivers' licenses centers to get photo-IDs. Some may be shut-ins; others may not have timely access to a birth certificate and other records.

An elderly African-American woman in Chattanooga, for example, had great difficulty a few months ago accessing a copy of a marriage license to affirm her maiden name on a hard-to-get birth certificate. As the media watched, she then had to wait hours in line on three different occasions at a drivers' license center to finally obtain a voter-ID license.

Tennessee makes it harder than most states for voters the GOP doesn't want to vote. Of the state's 95 counties, less than half have drivers' license center with photo ID capacity. Gov. Bill Haslam and the Secretary of State over the state's election commissions still refuse to give our convenient local county election commissions a photo-ID machine and authority to confirm voter registration and issue photo IDs.

The most closely watched legal contests against ALEC-inspired strict voter ID laws are those in the presidential battleground states of Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Wisconsin. Justice Department lawyers, however, are examining similar laws in South Carolina, Texas, Mississippi and Alabama, which due to their racist Jim Crow voting history must pass clearance under Section 5 of the federal Voting Rights Act.

The Justice Department lawyers should help Memphis Mayor A.C. Wharton, who is rightly pursuing a challenge of Tennessee's voter ID law. Given Tennessee's lurch to the right in recent elections, his lawsuit -- now shifted from federal court to a state chancery court -- may not matter much this time around.

Regardless, it would help an estimated 390,000 registered Tennessee voters whose current, valid, voter registration cards may be refused on November 6 because Tennessee has become one of the ALEC states that puts partisanship ahead of citizens' most sacred civil right -- the right to vote without undue state interference.

Comments do not represent the opinions of the Chattanooga Times Free Press, nor does it review every comment. Profanities, slurs and libelous remarks are prohibited. For more information you can view our Terms & Conditions and/or Ethics policy.
Leaf said...

Well said. Supressing the vote is anti-American.

September 12, 2012 at 11:09 a.m.
kochfacts said...

This editorial is biased, slanted, misleading, and a disservice to your readers. Americans have a First Amendment right to speak out on issues of public importance. The Supreme Court didn't “overturn” anything about that right -- quite the opposite, they reaffirmed it. It's astounding that the editorial board at the Chattanooga Times Free Press, itself owned by a privately-held company, would object to other companies speaking out in the identical way that they are. Also, the editorial fails to reveal the fact that groups across the political spectrum contribute to political causes, consistent with the Supreme Court’s ruling.

(Read about the media’s frequent mischaracterization of the Citizen’s United decision.)

As for laws concerning voter ID, guns, and abortion, Koch has taken no position on these issues and never has engaged in advocacy on these issue. With regard to ALEC, Koch has been a member of that organization for many years due to its nonpartisan work on economic freedom issues. As explained on, other extremist organizations and media have misrepresented Koch’s involvement in that group.

To learn more about Koch visit

September 12, 2012 at 10:05 p.m.
please login to post a comment

videos »         

photos »         

e-edition »


Find a Business

400 East 11th St., Chattanooga, TN 37403
General Information (423) 756-6900
Copyright, Permissions, Terms & Conditions, Privacy Policy, Ethics policy - Copyright ©2014, Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc. All rights reserved.
This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc.