Q: My doctor didn’t do a Pap smear at my last appointment. Doesn’t everybody need one yearly?
A: Although this may seem surprising, the answer is no. Pap smears screen for cervical cancer by detecting changes that precede cancer by many years. Several medical groups, including the American College of Ob/Gyn and the American Cancer Society, agree that for most healthy women: 1) Start Pap smears at age 21; if normal, repeat every three years; 2) From ages 30 to 65, it’s preferable to perform co-testing with a Pap smear and HPV test (for human papillomavirus), and if both are normal, repeat co-testing every five years. The reason for not performing annual Pap smears is because many changes on the cervix are transient and resolve spontaneously over time. More frequent screening detects these changes, prompting additional procedures, biopsies and even surgery, without increasing identification of cancer. Longer screening intervals avoid this pitfall and allow detection of meaningful changes. However, everyone is unique. Certain women require more frequent screening. Discuss this with your doctor. Together, you can determine the best screening schedule for you.
— Dr. Kristi Angevine-Hawken, University, Women’s Services; member, Chattanooga-Hamilton County Medical Society
Readers: To submit a question for a medical doctor, email it to Clint Cooper at email@example.com. See this space each week for answers.
related articles »
Q: My pregnancy test is negative. Could it be wrong?
Q. I heard the use of PSA is no longer recommended for prostate screening. Does this mean I should no ...
The questions fly in the face of a medical concept that seems indisputable: The earlier the diagnosis, the better.
Guidelines released in 2009 suggesting some screening tests are overused provoked a backlash locally among breast cancer survivors, advocacy groups ...