published Friday, May 10th, 2013

Drew's Views

  • photo
    A mother holds her daughter as the executive director for Chattanooga Organized for Action speaks to parents about saving their community Early Head Start program at North Chattanooga Recreation Center.
    Photo by Tim Barber /Chattanooga Times Free Press.

HEADLINE: Sequester brings cuts to North Chattanooga Head Start program

THE RECAP: The North Chattanooga Head Start is among sites across the nation closing because of federal sequestration. Federally funded Head Start services will be discontinued for 70,000-plus children throughout America, but North Chattanooga is the only site of the 15 in Chattanooga that will close. The move is expected to keep more than 60 children from the Head Start/Early Head Start programs.

DREW'S VIEW: Oh no! That means North Chattanooga parents are going to have to take responsibility for their own children, rather than pawning them off on a government program that has been proven ineffective. Heaven forbid!

Not one child who was, or would have been, served by the North Chattanooga Head Start program will be any worse off because it closed. That's because Head Start doesn't work. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services discovered as much in a recent study.

The government study, which hoped to find positive outcomes as a result of Head Start, instead found that, "Out of the 142 outcomes measured in four categories -- cognitive, social-emotional, health and parenting practices -- Head Start produced no measurable patterns of beneficial outcomes for its students." Zero.

Head Start also failed to "improve the school readiness of children from low-income families," which is kind of the whole point of Head Start.

Given the total ineffectiveness of Head Start and the program's staggering price tag ($200 billion and counting), it's too bad every Head Start classroom in America isn't shuttered and replaced with a voucher that allows low-income working parents to place their kids in a high quality pre-K or child care center.

•••

HEADLINE: East Ridge city manager pool down to zero

THE RECAP: Chris Dorsey, the last man standing in the East Ridge city manager job search, dropped out Tuesday after being offered the job and a salary of $120,000 a year. The search began with 82 applicants, but only four qualified for the position.

Eddie Phillips will remain interim city manager while also serving as public safety director.

DREW'S VIEW: With Dorsey turning down the East Ridge city manager gig -- apparently in hopes of landing the vacant Signal Mountain city manager post -- East Ridge residents (like yours truly) are left wondering why the city can't find a sizable pool of decent candidates to fill its empty city manager position.

The frequent turnover of the position doesn't help matters. Nor does the fact that the most recent city manager, Tim Gobble, was pressured to resign after a list of questionable actions, leaving a mess for the next city manager to clean up.

But the real reason East Ridge could only find four qualified applicants who wanted the position is the city's screwy charter. The nitwits sitting on the 2008 city charter commission included a passage requiring the city manager to hold a bachelor's degree in public administration.

How many people have you met in your life with a B.S. in public administration? If you know one, you know one more than most people. And how many of the small handful of people with a bachelor's in public administration want to run the East Ridge municipal government?

Here's how little sense the charter requirement makes: I have a master's degree in public policy, which is darn near the same thing as public administration -- and it's from a top-50 university -- and I'm not qualified to apply. But someone with a bachelor's degree in public administration from an online college is.

The East Ridge city manager gig isn't a bad job. The city has a lot to offer -- especially if you like tattoo shops, flea markets, payday loan outfits, pawn shops, thrift stores, fast food restaurants and disc golf courses that flood every time it sprinkles. Plus, judging by the City Council's willingness to offer Dorsey a $120,000 salary for a position that shouldn't pay a dime over $90,000, city leaders are willing to overpay significantly for the right person.

In the end, rather than trying to shoehorn in someone as city manager who isn't right for the city just to meet the charter's ridiculous requirements, East Ridge leaders should let interim city manager Eddie Phillips continue in the position until the charter can be properly amended to allow for a larger pool of qualified candidates. It's better to wait and make the right decision rather than to rush into (yet another) wrong one.

•••

HEADLINE: Signal Mountain police arrest 17 teen partygoers

THE RECAP: Signal Mountain police arrested the students from the private Baylor School, Girls Preparatory School and the McCallie School at a house party last weekend and charged them with drinking alcohol under age. Many of those arrested are days from graduating, and the incident is not expected to prevent their graduation.

DREW'S VIEW: Oh, to live in a community where the police department's greatest concern is breaking up a house party. There has to be a better use of tax dollars and police time than arresting a few high school seniors for drinking in a private residence. If not, the Signal Mountain Police Department is overstaffed and needs to cut some cops from its bloated force.

"Drew's views" is a weekly roundup of Free Press opinions about topics that appeared recently in the Times Free Press. Follow Drew Johnson on Twitter: @Drews_Views.

6
Comments do not represent the opinions of the Chattanooga Times Free Press, nor does it review every comment. Profanities, slurs and libelous remarks are prohibited. For more information you can view our Terms & Conditions and/or Ethics policy.
gjuster said...

Drew - What everyone seems to be missing from the Sequester (which people seem to forget was a compromise between Obama and the Republicans) is based upon all the doomsday scenarios that are playing out is that it appears that the federal government can't cut 1% of it's future budget without the sky falling. We are in serious trouble

May 10, 2013 at 8:03 a.m.
ldbf said...

Drew, you're pretty cold on Head Start, and it sounds like you just have preconceived ideas on wanting a voucher system so you're going to interpret (or let Fox interpret) the HHS study results to suit your agenda. Actually, I doubt you have actually looked at the study for yourself. Reuters examines it a little more thoroughly (and includes some other studies); Fox, well, is just Fox! Shame on you for your callousness!

//The program works to serve the most at-risk children, including those who are disabled, homeless or living in extreme poverty. It also enables families to advocate for their children by including them in program governance and ensuring that children and their families have access to education, housing, healthcare, nutrition and other support services.

The goal is to prepare children for success in kindergarten, extend outcomes beyond the classroom and contribute to overall preparedness for life.

That Head Start prepares children for kindergarten is clear from the findings of the HHS study. There also is overwhelming evidence, from hundreds of studies over four decades, that Head Start children benefit from the program throughout their lives.// http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2012/12/27/does-head-start-work/

May 10, 2013 at 12:55 p.m.
jesse said...

Drew, i think the kids got busted for gitting LOUD enough for the neighbors to call in on them, Then the cops hands were pretty much tied!I doubt that the cops are out patroling lookin for this sort of thing! If ,after answering the call they had left and someone got hurt or left in an auto and had an accident THEN they are in trouble!

May 10, 2013 at 5:01 p.m.
rumrunr said...

drew, can i get a voucher for a more "Compassionate conservative" point of view. like you view of head start not working, you just are falling short and i should have the ability (at your expense) to replace you with something i think will work

May 10, 2013 at 7:38 p.m.
conservative said...

Yes, Head Start is nothing more than a baby sitting service provided by the taxpayer and yes parents should raise their own children.

Why can't Liberals understand the most simple things?

May 11, 2013 at 7:51 a.m.
Leaf said...

Right, Jesse. One of the jobs of cops is to respond to calls. If they show up and people are breaking the law they get arrested. It's not some conspiracy.

May 13, 2013 at 9:23 a.m.
please login to post a comment

videos »         

photos »         

e-edition »

advertisement
advertisement

Find a Business

400 East 11th St., Chattanooga, TN 37403
General Information (423) 756-6900
Copyright, Permissions, Terms & Conditions, Privacy Policy, Ethics policy - Copyright ©2014, Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc. All rights reserved.
This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Chattanooga Publishing Company, Inc.