Cumberland County grand jury indicts couple on felony murder charges

Cumberland County grand jury indicts couple on felony murder charges

September 21st, 2013 by Alex Green in Local Regional News

Brittany Lina Yvonn Moser

Brittany Lina Yvonn Moser

Photo by Contributed Photo /Times Free Press.

Jacob Bennett

Jacob Bennett

Photo by The Knoxville News Sentinel /Times Free Press.

Eight days after four young people were found shot to death on Renegade Mountain in Cumberland County, Tenn., a grand jury indicted two suspects on murder charges.

Tennessee Bureau of Investigation officials now believe Jacob Allen Bennett, 26, and Brittany Lina Yvonn Moser, 25, tried to rob two of the victims -- Rikki Danielle Jacobsen, 22, and Domonic Lewis Davis, 17 -- during a marijuana exchange.

Bennett was arrested Sept. 13, the day after the slayings, in Rhea County. He was charged Friday with four counts each of premeditated murder and felony murder and two counts of attempted aggravated robbery.

Moser is Bennett's girlfriend, according to a TBI release, and was with him at the time of the quadruple murder. She was arrested Friday morning at her home, 1872 Railroad St. in Dayton, Tenn, and indicted on four counts of felony murder and two counts of attempted aggravated robbery.

Cumberland County Sheriff Butch Burgess said Friday afternoon that local and state officials have been working the case hard since Sept. 12, when Jacobsen and Davis were found dead along with Steven Michael Presley, 17, and Jonathan Raymond Lajeunesse, 16, in Jacobsen's vehicle.

Burgess said the case is wholly unusual for Cumberland County, a golf and shopping hub.

"That's the first time [local, longtime residents] can ever remember that many being killed at one time," he said.

Having suspects from outside the county made it tougher, too.

"Most of the [usual crime suspects] here in our county, we know them," he said.

Burgess said police have known for some time that Moser was in nearby Dayton.

Moser's neighbors, though, didn't know she was a suspect in the notorious multiple slaying. That's what Charity Sneed Schutt, who lives across the street from Moser's place, said Friday.

"It is a shock because she seemed so nice and we never thought she would do this," Schutt said.

Burgess said the sheriff's department has been cautioning Cumberland County residents about irrational fears that they could be the next targets.

"We kind of just, generally, told them that it was not something they needed to be fearful of," he said, adding that the crime always seemed to have a personal connection rather than being a random act of gun violence.

He believes evidence is in the state's favor in the case against Bennett and Moser.

"We've got, we think, a real good case," he said.

Bennett and Moser are being held away from general population inmates at the Cumberland County Jail "for their own safety," Burgess said.

Contact staff writer Alex Green at or 423-757-6731.