Document
Ooltewah lawsuit against school board and ex-employees
View
Document
School board response to Ooltewah lawsuit
View
The Hamilton County Board of Education has responded to the lawsuit filed against them in September by the main victim in the Ooltewah High School rape case.
In the 22-page response , the attorney representing the school board, Charles Purcell, asks that the case against the board be dismissed.
The school board members "acted as reasonable and prudent ... in furtherance of their discretionary duties," the response claims.
The lawsuit filed against the school board cites a long and violent history of hazing and sexual abuse of male student athletes . The 23-page lawsuit accuses school district and Ooltewah High School administrators and staff of knowing abuse was taking place and failing to protect students.
The plaintiff in this case is a former Ooltewah High School freshman who was raped by his basketball teammates with a pool-cue during the team's trip to Gatlinburg, Tenn., just days before Christmas. The victim, 15 at the time of the attack, sustained injuries so severe he was rushed to the hospital for emergency surgery.
The victim and his mother filed the lawsuit against the Hamilton County Board of Education, former Ooltewah High School Principal Jim Jarvis, the school's former Athletic Director Allard "Jesse" Nayadley and former head basketball coach Andre "Tank" Montgomery.
In the lawsuit, the plaintiffs asks that a jury decide the amount of damages the victim is entitled to receive from each defendant.
The response Purcell filed this week in federal court is not for the individuals named in the lawsuit, but just the school board.
In its response, the board says it isn't responsible for the alleged injuries the victim received from three older teammates, saying these players are the "sole and proximate cause of the alleged injuries sustained by the Plaintiffs."
Photo Gallery
Former Ooltewah basketball coach asks that charges of failure to report child sexual abuse be dismissed
View 8 Photos
Three former Ooltewah High School students have been convicted in connection with the pool-cue rape of the Plaintiff . The oldest of the perpetrators, who turned 18 soon after the attack, was convicted of aggravated rape and aggravated assault in Sevier County Juvenile Court and will be released from juvenile detention in coming weeks. The two other players, 16 at the time of the attack, were convicted of aggravated assault and will also be released soon.
The board's response argues that if anyone should have been aware the three boys may have committed this attack it would have been their parents, not the school board.
"The Plaintiffs have no legally cognizable action against [the school board] for negligent supervision," the response states.
The lawsuit against the board claims it failed to maintain adequate policies and training regarding student hazing and bullying . The board also did not adequately train employees about mandatory reporting of abuse, which according to the lawsuit created a climate where such misconduct was tolerated and encouraged due to a lack of consequence.
Photo Gallery
School board meets with attorneys about Ooltewah rape case
View 6 Photos
The lawsuit claims that the board's failure to have the proper policies and training in place means they should not be protected by the state's Governmental Tort Liability Act, which protects governmental boards from lawsuits and limits the amount of damages that can be paid. Attorneys say the board failed to protect the victim, and that Jarvis, Nayadley and Montgomery's negligent actions provide legal grounds to remove the board's immunity.
The board's response says it should be covered under tort law, as its members acted in the "scope of their employment."
"Therefore, the Plaintiffs may not recover from this Defendant," the response continues.
Also in the response, Purcell denies the plaintiffs' complaints and allegations, and cites a lack of evidence.
Responding paragraph by paragraph to the lawsuit, Purcell repeats many times the phrase: "Denied on the grounds that this Defendant is without sufficient information or knowledge to either admit or deny the allegations and strict proof of same is hereby demanded."
A response like this is not uncommon in a federal civil court case, and it's expected that a separate response will be filed on behalf of the former Ooltewah High School employees named as individuals in the lawsuit.
The attorneys representing the plaintiff are Douglas Fierberg and Monica Beck of the Fierberg National Law Group based in Washington, D.C., and Eddie Schmidt of Nashville.
Purcell is based in Jackson, Tenn., and works at Purcell, Sellers & Craig, Inc.
More Ooltewah rape case stories
Previously confidential Ooltewah rape settlement finally unveiled to Hamilton County school board members
Mom alleges Ooltewah High School failed to protect her son after he was attacked in class
State attorney: Insurer's settlement payments in Ooltewah High School sexual assault cases 'likely subject' to open records law
Gardenhire blasts Hamilton County school board over confidential settlements in Ooltewah rape cases
Second student in 2015 Ooltewah High School rape settles federal case
Hamilton County Schools reaches confidential settlement with one Ooltewah rape victim
Ooltewah rape case: School board agrees to negotiate settlement with victim
Civil claims in Ooltewah rape case headed to trial
Judge recuses himself from civil lawsuits linked to Ooltewah High School rape case
Hamilton County Board of Education attorneys move for separate trials in Ooltewah rape civil lawsuits
Greeson: More past mistakes mean more work for Hamilton County Schools leaders
Federal judge rules against school board for 2nd time in Ooltewah rape civil suits
Judge's ruling in Ooltewah rape civil cases puzzles some Hamilton County school board members
Hamilton County Schools attorney denies swaying Ooltewah High School inquiry
Attorneys for Ooltewah victims: Emails show district, investigator 'openly collaborating'
Ooltewah rape investigation: Judge rules school board lawyers must turn over communications
Attorneys for Ooltewah assault victims want to see private documents used to create report
Judge dismisses perjury charges against Gatlinburg detective in Ooltewah rape case
Attorney for former Ooltewah coaches wants to add more evidence to lawsuit
School district agrees to turn over key investigative file in Ooltewah rape case
Attorneys to argue whether private lawyer must turn over full Ooltewah investigative file
Judge sets trial date for detective charged with perjury in Ooltewah High School rape case
School district, former superintendent respond to Ooltewah rape case lawsuit
Judge: State, county and school district must respond to ex-Ooltewah employees' lawsuit
Ex-Ooltewah High staffers' lawsuit claims mistreatment in wake of rape case
Three former Ooltewah High School employees file federal lawsuit over rape case fallout
Analysis: Sex assaults in high school sports minimized as 'hazing'
Appeals court upholds local judge's ruling in connection with Ooltewah High School rape case
Gatlinburg detective facing charges in Ooltewah case continues to argue it should be dismissed
Ooltewah rape case set for trial in 2018, judge tells attorneys this case is a 'priority'
Date set for federal trial in Ooltewah High School rape case
Former Ooltewah High School employees deny culture of hazing and abuse
Lawmakers plan to rewrite child abuse reporting law following the Ooltewah High School rape case
Ooltewah rape case: Hamilton County Schools argues it shouldn't be held liable in second federal lawsuit
Lawmakers plan to rewrite child abuse reporting law following the Ooltewah High School rape case
Gatlinburg police detective charged in connection with Ooltewah rape case will appeal judge's decision
One year later: Ooltewah basketball
Lawsuit filed in Ooltewah sexual assault claims Hamilton County Schools covered up abuse
Judge dismisses charges against former Ooltewah High School basketball coach
Judge to decide whether to dismiss charges against former coach in Ooltewah rape case
Ooltewah High School rape case: Gatlinburg detective asks to appeal judge's decision allowing DA to prosecute
Ex-Ooltewah employees join school board in denying liability in Gatlinburg rape
Ooltewah rape case: School board files response, claims no responsibility
Attorney asks for lawsuit from Ooltewah victim against school board be dismissed
Judge allows DA to continue in perjury case against Gatlinburg detective
District attorney to continue prosecuting Gatlinburg detective for perjury in Ooltewah rape case
Former Ooltewah High School basketball coach hearing delayed
Former Ooltewah athlete spending less than a year in custody for rape conviction
Former Ooltewah students convicted of rape-related charges will be released this year
Ooltewah investigation: Schools failed to address reports of abuse
District attorney's report on Ooltewah High rape case criticizes school district
Cooper: Ooltewah rape suit adds to board woes
Attorneys representing victim of Ooltewah rape case file lawsuit
Lawsuit filed in Ooltewah High School rape case names school board and school employees as defendants
Former Ooltewah High School basketball coach appears in court
Former Ooltewah basketball coach asks that charges be dismissed
Victim lawsuit imminent after three teens convicted in Ooltewah rape case
All three defendants in Ooltewah rape case found guilty, two receive reduced charges
Judge in Ooltewah teammate rape case says he closed the trial to protect juvenile defendants
Former Ooltewah High School students charged with assaulting teammate appear in court
DA warns of problems if he's taken off Gatlinburg detective's perjury case
Judge says he needs more time on decision to remove Pinkston from prosecution
Sohn: Want to blame media for Ooltewah? Bring it on
Cooper: 'A culture of hazing'
Greeson: Hamilton County school leaders' transparency is welcomed, but more details needed from Ooltewah
Report calls Ooltewah High School's hazing training 'deficient'
District Attorney says there's no conflict of interest in his prosecution of Gatlinburg detective
A 'culture of hazing' existed on Ooltewah High School basketball team
Attorney says coach was singled out unfairly in Ooltewah High rape case
Williams and Haymon named new Ooltewah boys' basketball coaches
Gatlinburg detective wants Neal Pinkston disqualified from prosecuting his perjury case
Two Ooltewah High School administrators not returning after rape incident
Ooltewah coach, Gatlinburg detective plead not guilty in Ooltewah rape case
Two plead not guilty in connection with Ooltewah High School rape case
Ooltewah High School principal reassigned to new school
Jim Jarvis replaced at Ooltewah High as principals shuffled at Hamilton County schools
Three adults involved in Ooltewah rape case each face different outcome
Hamilton County District Attorney drops charges against Ooltewah High School assistant basketball coach
Detective charged with aggravated perjury could face harshest penalty in Ooltewah rape case
Detective investigating Ooltewah rape to be charged with aggravated perjury
Former Ooltewah coach Andre 'Tank' Montgomery could spend nearly a year in prison
Ooltewah basketball coach faces criminal charges in connection with teammate rape
Cooper: School board, public must work together
Greeson: Court diversion aside, Ooltewah decision now on Kirk Kelly
Ooltewah athletic director could return to job after deal
Ooltewah athletic director strikes deal in rape case
Cooper: Jill Levine hiring fuels intrigue
Kirk Kelly names Jill Levine chief academic officer
Sohn: It's school crunch time, and we have status quo
Cooper: School board votes to march in place
Hamilton County school board in disagreement over new interim superintendent
Kirk Kelly named interim superintendent of Hamilton County Schools
Sohn: All eyes on the school board as vote for interim superintendent nears
Greeson: Picking a school leader
Cooper: Schools chief should be dispassionate
Hamilton County school board narrows search for interim superintendent to 3 finalists
Veteran pair will manage Hamilton County schools for now
Greeson: Nightmare for Ooltewah victims continues with wrong ruling
Parents of victims in Ooltewah rape case upset suspect won't be tried as adult
Gatlinburg detective files $300,000 defamation lawsuit against Neal Pinkston
Accused Ooltewah rapist will be tried as a juvenile
Ooltewah rape victim testifies as judge weighs fate of the accused
Greeson: Smith's departure puts onus on school board to fix this
Cooper: Smith's exit leaves clean slate
Rick Smith quits after months of turmoil, revelation of scathing schools report
Greeson: HCDE moving forward
Clay Bennett cartoon: Rick Smith
Hamilton County school board refocuses on schools, not scandals
Adults charged in Ooltewah rape case turn themselves in for second time
School board meets for first time since deciding not to buy out Rick Smith's contract
Greeson: School board members let us down; Smith needs to go
One Ooltewah rape case suspect may be tried as an adult
Ooltewah substitute teacher and coach investigated for soliciting minor
Rick Smith plans to remain schools superintendent through 2019
Sohn: School board should stand for children
Cooper: Resignation still an option for Rick Smith
Greeson: School board buries heads in sand of insanity
Superintendent Rick Smith to remain at helm of Hamilton County school system
Decision looms today over superintendent's future
Three new candidates apply on final day to become Hamilton County's interim superintendent
Interim Hamilton schools chief candidate drops out of consideration, leaving one candidate
Top national attorney hired to represent victim in Ooltewah rape case
Could August re-election for four Hamilton County school board members impact decision on Rick Smith buyout?
Smith: We are all Ooltewah Owls
Gatlinburg police chief guarantees PD, city are taking allegations against detective seriously
In wake of Ooltewah incident, former NFL star points to three lies boys are taught about masculinity
Rick Smith's buyout plan riles Hamilton County school board members
Gatlinburg detective defends testimony, district attorney responds, claims detective perjured himself
Greeson: Rejecting rather than reporting student abuse our next job
TBI investigating Gatlinburg police detective for perjury in Ooltewah rape case
Detective's remarks in Ooltewah rape case fuel community outrage, calls for change
Sohn: Ooltewah's perverted culture of 'horseplay'
Cooper: Ooltewah must address its culture
Chattanooga's police chief blasts Gatlinburg detective for Ooltewah rape testimony
Ooltewah case moves forward: Detective says attack by students wasn't rape
Greeson: Mistakes after Ooltewah nightmare magnify previous hazing indifference
Wiedmer: Former NFL star Joe has manhood message for us all
Judge sends Ooltewah school officials' charges to grand jury
Judge renders decision in Ooltewah rape hearing
School board eyes external audit of school culture in wake of Ooltewah rape case
Oklahoma school district acted quickly, kept public informed in assault similar to Ooltewah rape
Basketball players charged in Ooltewah rape case scheduled to appear in court
Wanted: Interim superintendent to bring stability, leadership to Hamilton County schools
Sohn: Change agent and schools savior wanted
Ooltewah students post video to YouTube exemplifying positive qualities
Ooltewah High School officials' attempt to get charges dismissed fails, judge denies motion
School leaders will be called to testify in Ooltewah rape case
Sohn: The silver lining in Ooltewah's school heartbreak
Cooper: School board faces its own high-stakes test
Wiedmer: Smith won't be the last adult out of a job from Ooltewah mess
Rick Smith steps down in wake of Ooltewah High rape case
School board votes to buy out Superintendent Rick Smith's contract
Pressure mounting on school leaders in Ooltewah rape case
Ooltewah athletic staff begin to fight charges against them
School board, attorneys meet privately about Ooltewah rape case
Greeson: Superintendent Smith, and the rest of us, must do better by our students
School board meets behind closed doors, citing expected lawsuits over Ooltewah rape
More details revealed about Ooltewah rape case; Two juvenile suspects approved for bond
Cook: Crimes of silence in Ooltewah
Greeson: Those at fault at Ooltewah should face scary timese
A plea for change: Parents complain of bullying in schools; three adults face charges in rape case
Wiedmer: Life just turned scary for adults in Ooltewah case
Sohn: Let Ooltewah's darkest day be new dawn for schools
Cooper: Hazing policy examination better late than never
Parents claim harassment in Hamilton County schools has been happening for years
Ooltewah coaches charged for failing to report sexual assault of four players
School board member schedules panel discussion on Ooltewah assault
Hamilton schools out of compliance with state law for hazing, bullying policy
Greeson: Hamilton school board needs to rebuild trust after Ooltewah
Ooltewah High School's basketball coach reassigned to textbook depository
County officials break silence in Ooltewah sexual assault case
Sohn: Finally, school officials choose to lead
Wiedmer: Could Ooltewah situation become another Penn State?
Ooltewah basketball coach reassigned based on new facts
Sheriff Hammond doesn't rule out charges for adults involved in Ooltewah rape case
Opposing coach says Ooltewah players threatened his team hours before alleged assault
Petition demands Superintendent Rick Smith and Ooltewah Coach Tank Montgomery resign
Smith: What Hamilton County Schools got wrong about Ooltewah
Cook: Dominance, power and sports culture in Ooltewah
New charges sought against former Ooltewah basketball players
Court releases more details in Ooltewah rape case
Aunt of Ooltewah victim starts petition, wants perpetrators charged as adults
Sohn: School and county leaders must lead, not hide
Cooper: Public needed reassusrance surrounding Ooltewah incident
Greeson: School leaders, it's time to lead after Ooltewah mess
Judge has not issued an official 'gag order' in Ooltewah rape case
Ooltewah boys' basketball season cancellation affects other area schools
Ooltewah High School basketball season canceled; school officials under gag order
School board says no answers yet regarding Ooltewah assault case after meeting with legal counsel
Ooltewah basketball season canceled, effective immediately
Ooltewah students, community gather to pray for victim in assault, rape case
After Ooltewah incident, Mayor Andy Berke announces plan to stop bullying
Officials are staying quiet about Ooltewah basketball player rape case
Greeson: Outrage at Ooltewah now calls for action
Nerbun: Sports culture needs more character focus
District attorney to investigate more Ooltewah High assault allegations
Ooltewah High School's basketball game canceled
Ooltewah grads urge school to have external investigation of 15-year-old student's rape, assault
Attorney says Ooltewah coach being wrongly vilified in basketball player rape case
Experts say soul-searching needed in wake of Ooltewah athlete rape case
Sohn: Ooltewah High School basketball coaches should resign immediately
Ooltewah rape victim may have warned basketball coaches of abuse
Cooper: Nip hazing before it begins
Greeson: Ooltewah attack leaves pain, questions and prayers for the victim
Basketball players charged with rape of teammate won't be coming back to school
Ooltewah students charged with rape, assault after teammate injured with pool cue
Ooltewah High School basketball player undergoes surgery after being allegedly hazed by three teammates in Gatlinburg cabin
See Saturday's Times Free Press for the full story.