Follow this link to a related story: Video: Cleveland Police Chief Wes Snyder disputes newspaper story.
Emails between Snyder and reporter Todd SouthView
CLEVELAND, Tenn. - Cleveland's police chief on Wednesday denounced a Times Free Press report of a court case in which his own assistant chief said he failed to immediately launch official investigations into reports in 2008 that some of his officers were having sex with teenage girls.
Chief Wes Snyder called a news conference Wednesday and read a statement calling reporter Todd South's Tuesday story "grossly inaccurate" and "totally irresponsible."
According to Snyder's statement, "Mr. South reports that I had knowledge of drug and sexual abuse by members of this department prior to my internal affairs investigation. This is completely false.
"At the time of this incident, the District Attorney's Office, the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation and the Cleveland Police Department thoroughly investigated the alleged crimes and policy violations," the chief said.
He also said none of the department's administrators "had any knowledge or participated in any cover-up as it pertained to Officers Nathan Thomas, Dennis Hughes or Jonathan Hammons."
South's story, based on testimony from Hamilton County Circuit Court, said that in May 2008, Snyder ordered Assistant Chief Gary Hicks to speak to some officers and their supervisors about allegations the officers were giving alcohol and pills to young teens and having sex with them.
Snyder's department could supply no documentation that there was any investigation before December 2008, when details came out during an investigation into an on-duty officer being shot at a pill party at Hughes' home. Hughes and Thomas eventually were indicted on charges of having sex with 14- and 16-year-old girls.
After reading the statement Wednesday, Snyder refused to answer questions, including one from the Times Free Press asking him to confirm that South had asked him four times for comment on the story a week before it was published.
Snyder did not return a phone call later in the day.
Times Free Press Managing Editor Alison Gerber pointed out in a statement that information in South's original story originated from court testimony.
"Chief Snyder was given several opportunities to comment and did not respond. The Times Free Press stands by its reporter and the information published," Gerber said.
Hicks was out of the office Wednesday and could not be reached for comment.
South's story involved testimony on Nov. 17 in an employment lawsuit filed by former Cleveland detective Duff Brumley, who was fired in 2010.
Hicks was subpoenaed to testify about the work environment at the Cleveland Police Department.
During testimony, Hicks said the department received complaints before May 2008 that some officers were giving teenage girls alcohol and having sex with them. Other complaints alleged the officers were abusing prescription medications such as hydrocodone, Hicks testified.
Hicks testified that Snyder told him to meet with the accused officers and "get their attention." He said he met in May 2008 with the officers and their supervisors to let them know the conduct had to stop or they would be fired.
He said he wrote the message on a whiteboard during the meeting at the Cleveland Police Department but didn't actually speak to the officers. He testified that the officers and supervisors nodded their heads, also without speaking.
The Tennessee Department of Children's Services website states that, under state law, "all persons (including doctors, mental health professionals, child care providers, dentists, family members and friends) must report suspected cases of child abuse or neglect. Failure to report child abuse or neglect is a violation of the law."
After Hicks' testimony on Nov. 17, South asked Snyder on Nov. 21 for records of internal affairs investigations involving the suspected officers.
Snyder turned over a computer disk with nearly 500 pages of records from the December 2008 investigation into the accidental shooting case, but there were no records on the disc indicating any other investigations before or after that.
In the shooting case, on-duty officers Chris Mason and John Hammons were at the home of Hughes, who was off duty at the time, when Hughes shot Mason in the hand.
At that point, the Cleveland Police Department began an investigation. On Jan. 5, 2009, Bradley County District Attorney Steve Bebb asked the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation to enter the case, TBI spokeswoman Kristin Helm said Wednesday. Information was unavailable late Wednesday whether the agency had been asked to investigate the case before that, Helm said.
Investigators found that Hammons and Thomas were using pills without a prescription, and the allegations about the drugs and sex with the teenagers came out.
Thomas pleaded guilty in July 2010 to drug, forgery and statutory rape charges and was sentenced to six years in prison. Hughes pleaded guilty to two counts of statutory rape and was placed on probation, court records show.