Fisher: Hiding government mistakes won't make government better

Fisher: Hiding government mistakes won't make government better

May 21st, 2019 by Deborah Fisher in Opinion Columns

The Hamilton County Board of Education's attorney on Wednesday finally revealed to board members the settlement payout amount of $750,000 to a student sexually assaulted during a basketball tournament trip.

Attorney Scott Bennett indicated that this amount was previously confidential because its insurer had entered into a confidentiality agreement with the student and his family.

There is still another student with whom the school board's insurer reached a settlement payout. Bennett has not released that amount. The explanation is that the settlement is under seal in federal court.

More Ooltewah rape case stories

The Tennessee Attorney General and the Office of Open Records Counsel have both weighed in on the matter — and told the school board and its insurer, the Tennessee Risk Management Trust — that settlement agreements between governing bodies and private parties are public records. Further, any nondisclosure agreement or confidentiality agreement could make a settlement agreement void and unenforceable.

This is not new. It has been recognized by the Court of Appeals at least twice since 1999, and has been the opinion of the Tennessee Attorney General since 1996.

In 1996, the attorney general said, "An agreement by a governmental agency to restrict public access to public records that are not exempt under state law violates public policy and is unenforceable."

In responding to a question from an emergency communications district that had entered into a confidentiality agreement, the AG said, "By entering into an agreement to restrict access to public records for which no statutory exemption is available, the district would be attempting to create a new exemption from the Public Records Act," which is not allowable.

In May 1999, the Court of Appeals reached the same conclusion in a case involving a newspaper's request for a settlement agreement between the city of Memphis and the family of man who died while being restrained by the Memphis Police Department. After the newspaper sued under the Tennessee Public Records Act, the city finally released the settlement document which it had previously said it was prevented from doing because it was under seal in federal court.

On appeal, the court found in Contemporary Media Inc. v. City of Memphis that the city had willfully violated the Tennessee Public Records Act because it had known government settlements were public records and any confidentiality agreement entered into by the city would be contrary to law.

"A governmental entity cannot enter into confidentiality agreements with regard to public records," the court said. "The idea of entering into confidentiality agreements with respect to public records is repugnant to and would thwart the purpose and policy of the Act. Thus, the City could not lawfully enter into the agreement which it entered into with the family to keep the terms of the public record confidential."

In 2004, the Court of Appeals in The Tennessean v. the City of Lebanon reached this conclusion again in a case in which Lebanon paid a settlement to a widow of a man mistakenly shot by police.

With the clarity of these two cases, and fresh letters from the attorney general and Office of Open Records Counsel to the school board and Tennessee Risk Management Trust, urging toward disclosure, it is somewhat remarkable that the continued position appears to reject what is so apparently before them.

The school board's insurer, the Tennessee Risk Management Trust, is most likely considered a government entity under the law, according to the Office of Open Records Counsel. So even if the school board claims its insurer entered into an agreement without its knowledge or approval of the details, its insurer is also likely subject to the Public Records Act.

In parsing the school board attorney's statement to the Times Free Press last week, it seems to hang onto the idea that the settlement payout can continue to be confidential unless the student's family agrees to make it public.

"I understand that Mr. (Charles) Purcell (the attorney for TRMT) was able to use the attorney general's position to persuade the Doe attorney to waive the confidentiality agreement," Bennett said.

The fact that the school board or the Tennessee Risk Management Trust quite possibly agreed to, or sought, unlawful confidentiality of the settlement amounts seems to be lost.

The citizens of Chattanooga, and citizens of this state whose schools boards and county governments pay insurance premiums to the Tennessee Risk Management Trust, might consider why this issue is important.

In this case, the school district faced costly liability for its actions or nonactions related to the student assaults.

Our history must surely convince us that secrecy that hides the scope of government mistakes, including the cost, from the people will not make government better.

It is only through transparency that citizens have a full accounting of the impact of government decisions and that our chance to maintain self-governance will continue.

Deborah Fisher is executive director of Tennessee Coalition for Open Government.

Getting Started/Comments Policy

Getting started

  1. 1. If you frequently comment on news websites then you may already have a Disqus account. If so, click the "Login" button at the top right of the comment widget and choose whether you'd rather log in with Facebook, Twitter, Google, or a Disqus account.
  2. 2. If you've forgotten your password, Disqus will email you a link that will allow you to create a new one. Easy!
  3. 3. If you're not a member yet, Disqus will go ahead and register you. It's seamless and takes about 10 seconds.
  4. 4. To register, either go through the login process or just click in the box that says "join the discussion," type your comment, and either choose a social media platform to log you in or create a Disqus account with your email address.
  5. 5. If you use Twitter, Facebook or Google to log in, you will need to stay logged into that platform in order to comment. If you create a Disqus account instead, you'll need to remember your Disqus password. Either way, you can change your display name if you'd rather not show off your real name.
  6. 6. Don't be a huge jerk or do anything illegal, and you'll be fine.

Chattanooga Times Free Press Comments Policy

The Chattanooga Times Free Press web sites include interactive areas in which users can express opinions and share ideas and information. We cannot and do not monitor all of the material submitted to the website. Additionally, we do not control, and are not responsible for, content submitted by users. By using the web sites, you may be exposed to content that you may find offensive, indecent, inaccurate, misleading, or otherwise objectionable. You agree that you must evaluate, and bear all risks associated with, the use of the Times Free Press web sites and any content on the Times Free Press web sites, including, but not limited to, whether you should rely on such content. Notwithstanding the foregoing, you acknowledge that we shall have the right (but not the obligation) to review any content that you have submitted to the Times Free Press, and to reject, delete, disable, or remove any content that we determine, in our sole discretion, (a) does not comply with the terms and conditions of this agreement; (b) might violate any law, infringe upon the rights of third parties, or subject us to liability for any reason; or (c) might adversely affect our public image, reputation or goodwill. Moreover, we reserve the right to reject, delete, disable, or remove any content at any time, for the reasons set forth above, for any other reason, or for no reason. If you believe that any content on any of the Times Free Press websites infringes upon any copyrights that you own, please contact us pursuant to the procedures outlined in the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (Title 17 U.S.C. § 512) at the following address:

Copyright Agent
The Chattanooga Times Free Press
400 East 11th Street
Chattanooga, TN 37403
Phone: 423-757-6315