Cooper: Educational savings account proposal needs compromise

Cooper: Educational savings account proposal needs compromise

April 16th, 2019 by Clint Cooper in Opinion Free Press

Sen. Todd Gardenhire, R-Chattanooga, center, has said he won't support Gov. Bill Lee's bold educational savings account proposal in the Senate Finance Committee meeting today.

Photo by Erin O. Smith

We would like to believe there is still time for compromise on Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee's bold educational savings account proposal.

The new governor wants legislation, where previous voucher bills had failed, that would give children in districts with low-performing schools an amount of money that would allow them to attend a private school or to use the money in other ways that could enhance their education.

The proposal only applies to school districts in Hamilton, Knox, Davidson, Shelby and Madison counties, and the state-run Achievement School District, where the lowest performing schools reside.

But state Sen. Todd Gardenhire, R-Chattanooga, has said he won't vote for the bill in the Senate Finance Committee today.

If a senator from one of the few counties affected by the proposal doesn't support it, and the other Chattanooga senator (Bo Watson) has expressed doubts about it, the legislation could have trouble finding wider support in the full chamber.

If the proposal ultimately fails, many children in low-performing schools will go another year without an option for a better education.

Though time is drawing short for the session, we hope something can be worked out between the Lee administration and the legislature.

Gardenhire's problems with the bill are these: He believes it should not exclude illegal immigrants, he and other local legislators recently stuck their neck out to keep some Hamilton County schools from being added to the Achievement School District (and thus don't want to be falsely perceived as being against public schools), and he was not consulted by the administration on how such an educational savings account bill should be structured.

Our objections are these: We believe the educational savings accounts, at least for the early years of the program, only should be used to allow the students to go from public to private schools. In doing so, we believe the money should be sent to the schools and not the parents. And we believe the proposal should not apply to students in the district whose parents meet the income qualification but who are not in the lowest-performing schools.

In other words, we believe the proposal should be very limited at the outset — perhaps 5,000, rather than the 15,000 and 30,000 student caps suggested in the House and Senate versions of the bill, respectively. Even if it is a success, and we hope it would be, the caps then could be enlarged.

Gardenhire, several years ago, sponsored a bill that would allow children of illegal immigrants — children born in the U.S. and who are thus citizens — to pay in-state tuition at Tennessee public colleges. We endorsed that bill as we did another one he sponsored that would allow illegal immigrant children not born in the U.S. to pay in-state tuition at Tennessee public colleges. Our thinking was that since those students had to be established residents, graduates of state high schools and were going to pay tuition like everyone else, why shouldn't they get the in-state rate? That bill, though, has failed several times.

We understand that Gardenhire and other Hamilton County legislators went to bat to keep some Hamilton County schools out of the Achievement School District, but we don't believe that's reason enough to give a limited number of students another option for their education.

And as for being miffed for not being consulted about Gov. Lee's plans, well, perhaps it would have been better for the administration to initially have gathered members of those affected county delegations around the table. But if they did, the disagreements in that meeting might have kept any legislation from being launched.

We believe the governor had in mind when he came into office a proposal that would satisfy critics of previous voucher-type legislation. It didn't just pay for students to go from public to private schools but would allow them to use state money for other educational purposes. And it wouldn't cause any school districts to have fewer dollars if some students did leave; in fact, it would leave them with more money per capita.

Now, about that compromise ...

One thing we know is that Lee already has shown a willingness to compromise. In a bill the administration wanted that would make it easier to create charter schools, he was satisfied to allow a change that would keep local school boards in the loop when a charter school was created.

Perhaps, in that case, he could limit the number of students eligible in the first few years to determine how the program succeeds and to minimize its impact on public schools. And perhaps he could make children of illegal immigrants born in the U.S. eligible. And then perhaps Gardenhire could sign on (or help broker a different compromise).

Our concern is that every year students are not given more options for a better education, more of them will fall into a life that will not be all it could be. We think they deserve a better chance.

Getting Started/Comments Policy

Getting started

  1. 1. If you frequently comment on news websites then you may already have a Disqus account. If so, click the "Login" button at the top right of the comment widget and choose whether you'd rather log in with Facebook, Twitter, Google, or a Disqus account.
  2. 2. If you've forgotten your password, Disqus will email you a link that will allow you to create a new one. Easy!
  3. 3. If you're not a member yet, Disqus will go ahead and register you. It's seamless and takes about 10 seconds.
  4. 4. To register, either go through the login process or just click in the box that says "join the discussion," type your comment, and either choose a social media platform to log you in or create a Disqus account with your email address.
  5. 5. If you use Twitter, Facebook or Google to log in, you will need to stay logged into that platform in order to comment. If you create a Disqus account instead, you'll need to remember your Disqus password. Either way, you can change your display name if you'd rather not show off your real name.
  6. 6. Don't be a huge jerk or do anything illegal, and you'll be fine.

Chattanooga Times Free Press Comments Policy

The Chattanooga Times Free Press web sites include interactive areas in which users can express opinions and share ideas and information. We cannot and do not monitor all of the material submitted to the website. Additionally, we do not control, and are not responsible for, content submitted by users. By using the web sites, you may be exposed to content that you may find offensive, indecent, inaccurate, misleading, or otherwise objectionable. You agree that you must evaluate, and bear all risks associated with, the use of the Times Free Press web sites and any content on the Times Free Press web sites, including, but not limited to, whether you should rely on such content. Notwithstanding the foregoing, you acknowledge that we shall have the right (but not the obligation) to review any content that you have submitted to the Times Free Press, and to reject, delete, disable, or remove any content that we determine, in our sole discretion, (a) does not comply with the terms and conditions of this agreement; (b) might violate any law, infringe upon the rights of third parties, or subject us to liability for any reason; or (c) might adversely affect our public image, reputation or goodwill. Moreover, we reserve the right to reject, delete, disable, or remove any content at any time, for the reasons set forth above, for any other reason, or for no reason. If you believe that any content on any of the Times Free Press websites infringes upon any copyrights that you own, please contact us pursuant to the procedures outlined in the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (Title 17 U.S.C. § 512) at the following address:

Copyright Agent
The Chattanooga Times Free Press
400 East 11th Street
Chattanooga, TN 37403
Phone: 423-757-6315