Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Final twist doomed Delashmitt death case

final-twist-doomed-delashmitt-death-case
final-twist-doomed-delashmitt-death-case

PDF: Suspension order for TN PDF: Suspension order for GA

Mitchell Delashmitt was offered a plea bargain to end his child rape and murder case because “we were tired of baby-sitting” the state’s key medical witness, the McMinn County prosecutor said Thursday.

Dr. Ronald Toolsie conducted the autopsy on Angel Mae Delashmitt, whose body was found in a pond in June 2003. Based on Dr. Toolsie’s work, Mr. Delashmitt was charged with raping his 14-month-old daughter and shaking her to death.

Since then, Dr. Toolsie’s criminal drug charges and medical licensure problems contributed to several delays in Mr. Delashmitt’s trial, which started Tuesday and ended Wednesday morning before a jury even was seated.

“We were tired of baby-sitting him,” Assistant District Attorney Jim Stutts said. “We were hoping to at least keep him presentable for a trial, knowing his credibility was going to be questioned.”