Congress shied away for years from the idea of fixing a blanket federal requirement for online businesses to collect and remit state and local sales taxes on online purchases. The bill now being debated in the Senate — the Marketplace Fairness Act — tackles this needlessly thorny issue from a different angle. It would give state governments the option to require all but small businesses, those with sales of less than $1 million, to collect and remit state and municipal sales taxes.
Adoption of this state option should be an easy call for Congress, but apparently nothing related to taxes and business lobbyists is easy. A uniform federal law would have been desirable and more efficient. But the Marketplace Fairness Act is the next best measure. Certainly its passage is necessary.
Online businesses and retailers that now escape paying their fair share of state and local taxes are unfairly undermining the nation’s bricks-and-mortar stores on Main Street and in malls. Their tax avoidance robs communities everywhere of local jobs and local taxpayer support for the myriad public services that taxpayers and shoppers themselves rely on for essential public services in their home communities.
Online tax avoidance in many cases also directly sponges off bricks-and-mortar stores by enabling shoppers to browse and test products they see in local stores, and then to go online to purchase them just to avoid local sales taxes. The end result of all this tax unfairness, of course, is that it will let online merchants eventually drive local businesses, jobs, tax revenue and local commercial vitality into the ground.
This mercenary dynamic explains why eBay is fiercely contesting the Marketplace Fairness Act. Its sales strategy reflects the model that Amazon has now outgrown: eBay, too, wants to cannibalize the sales of bricks-and-mortar stores long enough to get big enough and rich enough in market-share to have huge warehouses everywhere. Though this process would make billionaires of online CEOs, it would kill many Main Street businesses and shopping malls in many communities.