Skip to main content
Tuesday, November 17, 2026Nov 17

Building a brand-new home next to a really old one has challenges

new-homes-old-neighborhoods
new-homes-old-neighborhoods
photo Allen and Louise Crowell are building a new home in St. Elmo. Because of the neighborhood’s designation on the historic registry, the couple’s home must earn approval from the Community Association of Historic St. Elmo.
photo When Stuart and Jonesy Wood built a new garage behind their Ochs Highway home, they had to have the plans for the building approved by the St. Elmo historic committee. The materials on the exterior of the garage, pictured in the background, had to match those on their home.
photo Allen and Louise Crowell had to get numerous permits to build a new home in historic St. Elmo.

Louise and Allen Crowell have built more than 50 homes in and around Middle Tennessee in the past 25 years. They’re hardly afraid of dealing with building codes, construction rules and landscaping guidelines in various neighborhoods.

Then they decided to build their own home in St. Elmo.

“It’s a heck of a lot harder to build a house here than it has been in any place I’ve ever built a house,” Allen says. “The other houses I’ve built only required two inspections — electrical and septic tank.”

Not so in St. Elmo. The rules of the Community Association of Historic St. Elmo committee dictate, among other things, what types of windows and doors you can have, what kind of fencing you can install, the proper style of gutters for your house and how to clean or repair your brick or masonry foundations and walls.

“Everything has to be approved upfront and, if it doesn’t meet the historic committee’s codes, you can’t build it,” Allen says. “If you do, you’ll have to tear it down and they’ll stop the construction. I’ve never dealt with anything like this before, but there’s a definite benefit. They don’t want us to build a shack.”