Olympic boxers Imane Khelif and Lin Yu-ting are women. They were born female. That is what doctors determined when they were infants, and it has been their sex ever since. They have never done anything to change it. Neither is transgender.
How remarkable it is, then, that famous critics of transgenderism have been wildly contradicting themselves over the last few days. They have declared for years that people are the sex they were assigned at birth, no matter what changes they make to their bodies. Now — with no evidence aside from the more traditionally masculine build of Khelif from Algeria and Lin from Taiwan — they have decided the two are men and insultingly bandy that about in interviews and hateful social media posts.
Children’s author J.K. Rowling, who has become an informal figurehead of the anti-trans movement, described Khelif’s win as “a man beating a woman in public for your entertainment” and posted other denigrating comments calling Khelif male.
Interesting that Rowling and other critics, such as vice presidential candidate Sen. JD Vance and tech entrepreneur Elon Musk had no objection when these two women boxed during the 2021 Tokyo Olympics — and lost to multiple other women, taking no medals. No complaints that the winning female boxers in Tokyo were unfairly beating up on men.
It was Khelif’s surprising victory last week over Italian boxer Angela Carini that got everyone worked up. Not surprising that Carini could lose — she also lost her first bout in the Tokyo Games — but she withdrew so quickly, after a heavy blow to her face. Her critics claimed the force of the blow must have been due to Khelif’s level of male hormones or male something.
