Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Barrett: Fair or not, spill is now shorthand for Obama’s presidency

The president’s straw-grabbing response to the oil spill inspires no confidence, but I have to admit it’s hard for me to pile as much of the blame on him as others think he deserves.

The fact is, it’s a big mess with no ready fix. We’re all grabbing straws.

Calls for the government to seize BP’s assets and “take control” are, of course, disturbing. But more than that, they’re silly: The feds rarely have a clearer idea about how to run things than the industries that have actually been running those things. Heck, we’d have a BP-scale disaster every other Tuesday if Harry Reid were in charge of deep-water drilling. But unlike nebulous health care, where it may be years before the catastrophe of federal dominion becomes obvious, taking over BP would make government ineptitude instantly apparent as the oil kept right on spilling.

Still, whatever path the president may take, he is suffering a teeth-rattling PR hit. A new Public Policy Polling survey of Louisiana residents asks, “Who do you think has done a better job in helping Louisiana to deal with crisis: George W. Bush or Barack Obama?”

The results? Half say President Bush did a better job – presumably with Hurricane Katrina since no other overriding Louisiana crisis was evident during his time in office. Only 35 percent say President Obama has performed better.