Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Cleaveland: Tackling health-care reform in the courts

tackling-health-carereform-in-the-courts
tackling-health-carereform-in-the-courts
photo Dr. Clif Cleaveland

Recent decisions by federal courts have blocked or limited key provisions of the Affordable Care Act. These verdicts have succeeded where efforts of the U.S. House of Representatives to derail the law have failed.

The U.S. Supreme Court set the stage for reshaping the ACA with decisions released in June 2012. A majority of the justices upheld the constitutionality of the individual mandate requiring most people to maintain a minimal level of health insurance beginning in 2014. By a 7-2 vote, the court rejected a suit that the entire ACA should be invalidated.

The most profound verdict by the court invalidated the ACA provision to expand Medicaid coverage. This section of the law required each state to expand its Medicaid program to cover persons earning up to 138 percent of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL). The federal government would pay the full cost of expansion for three years and then cover 90 per cent of the costs thereafter.

By a 5-4 vote, the Court ruled that Medicaid expansion was unconstitutional in that it coerced states to behave in a manner opposed by legislatures. This decision reduced from 17 million to 11 million the number of previously uninsured persons who would have been insured under the original ACA. Twenty-six states, including Kentucky and Arkansas, and the District of Columbia elected to expand their Medicaid programs. Each received federal support for the expansion.

On June 29, the Supreme Court issued another 5-4 decision (Burwell vs. Hobby Lobby) that addressed ACA provisions that contraceptives should be included in health services available for women at no additional cost. The majority ruled that this requirement violated federal laws that protected the religious liberty of companies that were privately held by religious families. Under the ruling, birth control pills, intrauterine devices and morning-after pills did not have to be included as covered benefits for female employees of these two companies.