When Signal Mountain makes its appeal to a three-member TSSAA Board of Control panel Thursday, odds are that the TSSAA ruling will be upheld.
The TSSAA ruled on Oct. 7 that the Eagles had used an ineligible [out of zone] player and vacated six wins. The ruling virtually eliminated any hopes the 2010 Class 2A state champions had of participating in their first Class 4A playoffs although they were 6-1 at the time that ruling was handed down.
Signal Mountain officials maintain a difference in interpretation. They believed Tim McClendon was eligible because he had been granted a hardship by the Hamilton County Department of Education to attend their school. They listed his address correctly (he lives in Brainerd) and then entered Signal Mountain as his zone on the TSSAA’s online eligibility form.
However, the TSSAA has maintained, probably for eons, that zoning hardships are not automatic approval for athletic participation.
Now, right or wrong, how many times has an appeal been overturned? And if it becomes an issue for the courts, how many legal battles has the TSSAA lost? Answer: Very few and never. Even the case by Brentwood Academy, which went to the U.S. Supreme Court, finally came out in the TSSAA’s favor.
