The city of Knoxville faced a skeptical Tennessee Supreme Court in its bid to use the judicial system to try to force video streaming providers Netflix and Hulu to pony up cable television franchise fees.
“Why did it take so long?” Justice Holly Kirby asked attorney Justin Hawal on why the city waited more than a decade to sue the firms. “Suddenly, municipalities are waking up and going, ‘Wait a minute, Netflix and Hulu, all these streaming services, are killing [cable],’ but this [cable television franchise] statute’s been [on the books] since 2008.
“Knoxville is just now waking up?” Kirby pressed. “It’s been a long time since [Netflix and Hulu] came into existence.”
The city is asking the state’s high court to declare that video streaming services, which rely on the internet, are equivalent to cable television providers, which rely on infrastructure on public rights-of-way.
It’s a first-of-its-kind lawsuit in Tennessee but is one of many being filed and litigated across the nation by state and local governments seeking to force Netflix and Hulu to pay franchise fees.