NASHVILLE – A Nashville judge overturned the conviction and 22-year prison sentence for a man whose case was championed as the first successful prosecution of a sex trafficking customer in Tennessee.
Criminal Court Judge Mark Fishburn overturned a jury’s 2014 decision that found 36-year-old Michael Kohlmeyer guilty of trafficking for a commercial sex act, The Tennessean reported.
Fishburn ruled the evidence didn’t support a conviction under the current language of the state’s new sex trafficking law. The Nashville District Attorney’s Office is appealing. Kohlmeyer remains in custody on charges pending in Gibson County.
According to trial testimony, Kohlmeyer contacted a woman who was using the name “Allie” and they talked for more than 90 minutes over two days in June 2013. In those messages, Kohlmeyer offered “5,000-plus for you and someone YOUNG!”
The woman went to police, and Nashville Detective Sheba Cantrell took over, posing as the prostitute. Authorities say Cantrell never posed as a child, but had conversations with Kohlmeyer about what age of girls he was looking for. Kohlmeyer replied, “just over 8 not over 16,” according to testimony.
