Skip to main content
Tuesday, November 17, 2026Nov 17

Judge denies new trial to Russell Maze, who was convicted of shaking baby to death

Photo by Martin B. Cherry / Nashville Banner / Judge Steve Dozier questions Dr. Lawrence Hutchins during a hearing related to Russell Maze's quest for post-conviction relief.

In a pair of orders filed Oct. 28, Davidson County Criminal Court Judge Steve Dozier ruled that Russell Maze, convicted of shaking his baby son Bryan Alexander to death more than two decades ago, will not get a new trial. 

Maze has twice been convicted of causing the injuries that led to his son’s death after “Baby Alex” was taken to the emergency room in May 1999. The child died several months later after he was found unresponsive at daycare and taken back to the hospital. Alex was in foster care at the time of his death after a doctor diagnosed him with abusive head trauma during his initial visit to the hospital. 

However, recent developments cast doubt on Maze’s guilt. In December 2023, the Davidson County District Attorney’s Conviction Review Unit asked Dozier to vacate Maze and his wife Kaye’s convictions. “This Office knows of clear and convincing evidence establishing Ms. Maze and Mr. Maze were both convicted of crimes they did not commit,” wrote District Attorney Glenn Funk. At a March 2024 hearing, Dozier stuck to his original ruling.

In September 2024, Dr. Bruce Levy, who examined Alex in 2000, recanted his original testimony in a sworn affidavit. If called to testify now, he said, he would say that Alex died of a “natural disease” process. Levy’s reversal led to an August 2026 Tennessee Supreme Court ruling that opened the door for further legal action, allowing the Mazes to pursue relief based on Levy’s affidavit. 

Last month, Dozier shut that door once more. In one order, he disagreed that Levy’s affidavit constituted “newly discovered scientific evidence.”