Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Jury finds Sewanee and student at fault; awards student $26,500

jury-finds-sewanee-and-student-fault-awards-50000-
jury-finds-sewanee-and-student-fault-awards-50000-
photo “John Doe” exits the Joel W. Solomon Federal Building earlier in his trial with his mother, Mary “Doe”, left, and attorneys Elisha King, bottom right, and Charles B. Wayne, top right.

A former student who engaged in a three-year legal battle with Sewanee: The University of the South said the Friday verdict in his case proves the school unfairly handled a rape accusation against him in 2008.

A federal jury awarded $26,500 to the former student, identified only as John Doe in court documents, who sued the school for negligence and breach of contract. He had asked for $5.5 million.

University spokeswoman Laurie Saxton said in a news release Friday that the low amount of damages shows that the jury thought Doe “received a fair hearing.”

“It is significant that John Doe essentially was awarded only a refund of his tuition and that the jury declined to award damages for any injury to his reputation, emotional injury, or loss of earning capacity,” Saxton wrote.

Charles Wayne, one of Doe’s two Washington D.C.-based attorneys, said after the hearing that, even though they are disappointed in the award, the jury’s verdict “confirms what we have been saying all along – the verdict is a victory for the rights of students accused of sexual assault on campus.”