Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Review: In ‘Secret Token,’ Andrew Lawler excavates theories surrounding vanished colony of Roanoke

Andrew Lawler / Photo by R. Plaster
Andrew Lawler / Photo by R. Plaster
photo “The Secret Token: Myth, Obsession and The Search for the Lost Colony of Roanoke” / Photo by Anchor Books

“THE SECRET TOKEN: MYTH, OBSESSION AND THE SEARCH FOR THE LOST COLONY OF ROANAKE” by Andrew Lawler (Anchor [reprint], 448 pages, $17).

In “The Secret Token: Myth, Obsession and The Search for the Lost Colony of Roanoke,” Andrew Lawler ironically makes a decent case against getting too curious about the first English settlement in North America. Get too close to the puzzling details of Roanoke – a vanished community, a handful of contradictory clues, a cast of eccentric characters making inexplicable decisions – and you might just find yourself sucked into an enigma with no end.

Lawler creates a vibrant portrait of the historical events surrounding the establishment of the Roanoke colony in the Outer Banks region of North Carolina and the colony’s subsequent disappearance. He also illuminates the “gravitational attraction” of this mystery for generations of historians, archaeologists, genealogists and conspiracists. After more than four centuries, the search for answers about the fate of the vanished settlers continues to lure fresh recruits.

From the start, Lawler presents the story of Roanoke as a “haunting as much as a history.” “To die is tragic,” Lawler writes in his introduction, “but to go missing is to become a legend, a mystery.” Lawler argues that the “delicious dread” Roanoke provokes in us feeds the part of our story-loving psyches that are drawn to unresolved destinies.

As an extension of that fascination, Lawler also positions Roanoke as a potent, emblematic national myth. One purpose of his investigation is to reveal the legacy of the story, not just the events. Such national myths, he writes, “help us get our bearings in each age.” The Roanoke story acts as a touchstone for the cultural landscape surrounding it in any given era.