Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Hamilton County woman who stabbed her brother to death sentenced to live in senior group home

judge-considers-mental-health-conditions-orde
judge-considers-mental-health-conditions-orde
photo Glenda Forrest

She came into the courtroom in a yellow jumpsuit, using a walker to find her seat.

Glenda Forrest was facing a first-degree murder charge for stabbing her 65-year-old brother to death in April 2014. But on Thursday in Hamilton County Criminal Court, attorneys agreed in a plea deal to reduce that charge to voluntary manslaughter – a class C felony that carried six to 10 years in prison instead of life behind bars.

Then, by the end of a lengthy sentencing hearing that included an in-depth discussion on the intersection of mental health, addiction and trauma in the modern justice system, Judge Barry Steelman sent Forrest to Mental Health Court on supervised probation. He also ordered the 65-year-old woman to get alcohol monitoring.

“The biggest reservation I have is that I’m not sure if any one of us in this place would want to share a room with her,” Steelman said as he weighed close to four hours of witness testimony. “We can all agree to put her in a Senior Manor facility, but I’m not sure anybody can sleep at night, or turn the lights out. And that’s what concerns me the most.”

Forrest, however, had no prior criminal convictions, Steelman said.