Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Family wants answers about Cohutta man’s fatal collision with police cruiser

photo In their living room in Cohutta, Ga., Leon Thurman’s family members talk about the events that took his life on March 5. From left are his widow, Virginia Thurman, his son, Michael, and daughter, Missy Mercer.

The son and daughter of a Cohutta, Ga., man killed in a fiery crash two weeks ago want to know how fast a police officer was driving when his cruiser smashed broadside into their father’s Dodge Neon.

“This could have been avoided,” said Michael Thurman. “[I know] in my heart this shouldn’t have happened.”

Thurman’s 70-year-old father, Leon, a longtime newspaper carrier for the Dalton Daily Citizen, was delivering papers about 1:30 a.m. on March 5 when he crossed four lanes on Cleveland Highway trying to get to a side road.

Varnell police officer James Smith, a six-year veteran, was on the highway, driving from Dalton to Varnell, in an area where the posted speed limit is 45 mph.

Police later said his blue lights weren’t on, and 911 records indicate that he wasn’t responding to a call. And in his front seat was a 19-year-old male passenger, who authorities later said was participating in a citizen ride-along.