Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Judge calls for sentencing overhaul as Hixson man’s prison term upheld, but not ‘just’

judge-calls-sentencing-overhaul-hixson-mans-prison
judge-calls-sentencing-overhaul-hixson-mans-prison
photo Edward Lamar Young of Hixson

A federal appeals court judge on Thursday called for an overhaul of federal sentencing rules after upholding the 15-year prison term of a Hixson man convicted of possessing seven shotgun shells.

Lawmakers need to reconsider the Armed Career Criminal Act which “over-criminalizes” certain conduct by imposing mandatory minimum sentences for some crimes, said Jane Branstetter Stranch of the U.S. 6th Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati.

Stranch’s comments came in a concurrence to an opinion by the appeals court upholding the sentence of Edward Lamar Young of Hixson, Tenn. Young pleaded guilty in January 2013 to being a felon in possession of ammunition after being found with the shells, which he inadvertently acquired while helping a neighbor dispose of her late husband’s belongings.

“Precedent compels us to conclude that this sentence does not violate the Constitution,” Stranch said. “But holding that a sentence is constitutional does not make the sentence just.”

In an unsigned majority opinion, Stranch and judges Richard Allen Griffin and Helen White declined to address the fairness of Young’s sentence, instead saying binding precedent required that it be upheld.