Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Alabama judge: Court opinion’s language too sexually graphic

Gavel and scales
Gavel and scales

BIRMINGHAM, Ala. – Judges on a state appeals court included too much graphic detail about a sex abuse and sodomy case in a written opinion upholding a man’s convictions, one of their colleagues said Friday.

Judge Michael Joiner said he agreed with the decision of his three peers on the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals to uphold William Brownlee’s convictions on the charges. Brownlee is serving 20 years in prison after being convicted of repeatedly molesting an underage girl.

But Joiner took issue with the other judges’ decision to include graphic portions of her testimony from Brownlee’s trial, held last year in Baldwin County. The opinion does not include the victim’s name, just initials.

Quoting a 2008 law review article, Joiner said courts are a “leading purveyor of incredibly intimate and embarrassing information about both adults and children who happen to be pulled into the judicial system.”

Joiner said he didn’t mean to suggest that Brownlee’s “deplorable crimes should be minimized or hidden,” or that it’s easy to determine how much detail of a crime should be included in an appellate decision.