Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Appeals court to hear judge shopping case

PDF: Court of criminal appeals

An absence of case precedent when it comes to issues of judge shopping raised here last year has led the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals to agree to hear a local man’s plea to dismiss charges pending against him in Hamilton County General Sessions Court.

The granting of an “interlocutory appeal” — the appeal of a case before it is fully litigated at the local level — is rare, legal experts say.

But it is “warranted under the circumstances of this case,” the Court of Criminal Appeals wrote in its June 28 order, and also “in the interests of judicial economy.”

Put another way, defendant Gary Wayne McCullough might not have to go through a criminal trial at all if the higher court ultimately rules that evidence of judge shopping in his boating under the influence case is serious enough that it denied him a fair chance from the beginning.