Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Punishing the poor? Court policies can keep the destitute in a debt cycle

In this April 16, 2019, photo, Johnny Gibbs helps his disabled father, Mike, 65, into their home in Liberty, Tenn. Johnny Gibbs has been trying to get a valid driver's license for 20 years, but he can't afford it. To punish him for high school truancy in 1999, Tennessee suspended his ability to get a license until he turned 21. When Gibbs couldn't pay for traffic violations, he ended up serving jail time and probation. But rather than wiping his fines and allowing him to obtain a valid license, he wound up even more deeply in debt because he had to pay a monthly supervision fee to a private probation company. (AP Photo/Mark Humphrey)
In this April 16, 2019, photo, Johnny Gibbs helps his disabled father, Mike, 65, into their home in Liberty, Tenn. Johnny Gibbs has been trying to get a valid driver's license for 20 years, but he can't afford it. To punish him for high school truancy in 1999, Tennessee suspended his ability to get a license until he turned 21. When Gibbs couldn't pay for traffic violations, he ended up serving jail time and probation. But rather than wiping his fines and allowing him to obtain a valid license, he wound up even more deeply in debt because he had to pay a monthly supervision fee to a private probation company. (AP Photo/Mark Humphrey)

LIBERTY, Tenn. – Johnny Gibbs has been trying to get a valid driver’s license for 20 years, but he just can’t afford it.

To punish him for high school truancy in 1999, Tennessee officials told him he would not be able to legally drive until he turned 21. He drove anyway, incurring two tickets and racking up more than $1,000 in fines and fees.

Like other low-income defendants in similar situations across the nation, Gibbs couldn’t pay and ended up serving jail time and probation. That incurred another cost: a monthly supervision fee to a private probation company.

Rather than risk another arrest, Gibbs, now 38, decided to quit driving, which he said makes it nearly impossible to work. He said he spent several years living in a motel room with his mother, his disabled father and his sister before they all became homeless. In August, the family found housing in a dilapidated trailer, miles from the nearest town or food source.

“Honestly, I feel like I’m being punished for being poor,” Gibbs said.