Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Fired Cleveland police detective claims he was denied fair hearing

fired-cleveland-police-detective-claims-he-was-den
fired-cleveland-police-detective-claims-he-was-den
photo Duff Brumley, left, a former Cleveland Police Department detective who was fired last year, speaks to one of his attorneys during a civil suit he filed against the city of Cleveland, Tenn., in W. Neil Thomas III’s Circuit Courtroom on Thursday.

A former Cleveland, Tenn., police detective is suing for his job back, claiming he didn’t receive a fair hearing when fired last year.

During testimony in Hamilton County Circuit Court on Thursday, Duff Brumley described an ongoing, openly hostile work environment created by Cleveland Police Chief Wes Snyder and 10th Judicial District Attorney Steven Bebb in the years preceding his firing.

Judge Neil Thomas III set out strict rules on what he would consider in Brumley’s appeal of Cleveland City Manager Janice Casteel’s decision to uphold the August 2010 firing.

Much of what he can do is limited to other court rulings on requests for appeal on city and county agency actions, Thomas said.

Thomas allowed Brumley’s attorney, Gerald Tidwell, to call witnesses as an offer of proof of Brumley’s claims. The judge will decide if Brumley should get his job back.