Skip to main content
Wednesday, November 18, 2026Nov 18

Vols top five: Peyton Manning went out as SEC champion, NCAA all-time wins leader

AP photo by Mark Humphrey / Tennessee quarterback Peyton Manning takes the field for his last home game as a Vol on Nov. 29, 1997. Tennessee beat Vanderbilt 17-10 that day.
AP photo by Mark Humphrey / Tennessee quarterback Peyton Manning takes the field for his last home game as a Vol on Nov. 29, 1997. Tennessee beat Vanderbilt 17-10 that day.

EDITOR’S NOTE: This is the fourth story in a series counting down the top five players in University of Tennessee football history. The Times Free Press previously published companion series on Alabama (May 4-8) and Georgia (May 11-15).

Let’s go ahead and get those Peyton Manning negatives out of the way from his days at Tennessee.

In his four seasons shining at quarterback for Phillip Fulmer’s Volunteers, the heralded son of Southeastern Conference legend Archie Manning went 0-4 against Eastern Division rival Florida.

Never mind that Manning didn’t even start the 1994 contest and was on the bench as the Gators built a 17-0 lead within the first 18 minutes. Never mind that he played brilliantly inside the Swamp in 1995, passing for 326 yards and two touchdowns, and was not part of a Vols defense that collapsed after halftime. He threw for a school-record 492 yards and four scores in the 1996 matchup, but his touchdown count was matched by his number of interceptions, and his 353 yards and three touchdowns during his final crack at Florida will forever be overshadowed by Tony George’s 89-yard interception return for a score.

“It bothers me that we never did beat Florida,” Manning told reporters after the 33-20 loss in 1997, “but I can’t control the way other people view Tennessee or view my career. I’ve got thick skin. I’m disappointed, but this is football.