Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

City asks court to dismiss BID lawsuit amid week of obstacles for the controversial district [document]

Phillip Noblett, Signal Mountain town attorney, speaks at Signal Mountain Town Hall in this file photo.
Phillip Noblett, Signal Mountain town attorney, speaks at Signal Mountain Town Hall in this file photo.

The City of Chattanooga has asked the court to drop a lawsuit filed by property owners to prevent the formation of the controversial Business Improvement District.

Late Thursday, the city filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit, filed by siblings Pam Rymer O’Dwyer, Charles D. Paty, Kem Alexander, Ralph Paty, Marion Gaye Paty Wade and fellow property owner William Wise, which claims the ordinance passed on July 30 to form the BID violated state statute for establishing such a district.

The city’s answer to the lawsuit says that the plaintiffs failed to “allege any colorable basis for the challenge to the ordinance,” arguing that since the BID was first heard as a petition-initiated ordinance, which failed, and then heard as a council resolution, the city was not required to wait before the second vote.

“We’re very hopeful that [the lawsuit] will be dismissed,” Kim White, President of local economic development nonprofit River City Co. said Friday.

The BID, which has been spearheaded by River City Co., passed the Chattanooga City Council in late July after failing earlier in the summer, despite claims from property owners that the reintroduction of the ordinance violated state law.