Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Supreme Court sides with defendant claiming jury race bias

In this photo taken March 3, 2107, the Supreme Court in Washington. The Supreme Court ruled Monday, March 3, 2017, that racial bias in the jury room can be a reason for breaching the centuries-old legal principle of secrecy in jury deliberations. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite)
In this photo taken March 3, 2107, the Supreme Court in Washington. The Supreme Court ruled Monday, March 3, 2017, that racial bias in the jury room can be a reason for breaching the centuries-old legal principle of secrecy in jury deliberations. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite)

WASHINGTON (AP) – The Supreme Court ruled Monday that racial bias in the jury room can be a reason for breaching the centuries-old legal principle of secrecy in jury deliberations.

The court ruled 5-3 in a Colorado case in which a juror reportedly tied defendant Miguel Angel Pena Rodriguez’s guilt to his Hispanic heritage.

The juror’s statements came to light after Pena Rodriguez was convicted. Two jurors reported that a third juror colleague determined that he was guilty because Pena Rodriguez is “Mexican, and Mexican men take whatever they want.”

Pena Rodriguez said the juror’s views, expressed behind the closed doors of the jury room, deprived him of a fair trial.

Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote for the majority “that blatant racial prejudice is antithetical to the functioning of the jury system and must be confronted in egregious cases like this one despite the general bar of the no-impeachment rule.” The court’s four liberal justices joined with Kennedy to form a majority.