Anticipating President Donald Trump’s likely end-of-term pardon spree, many commentators have suggested that given the breadth of the pardon power as set out in the Constitution, it would be lawful – if galling – for the president to issue proclamations that let his family off the hook for any and all federal offenses committed during his administration.
But it’s not so simple. A stronger case can be made that Trump cannot constitutionally wipe the slate clean for his kids.
Start with a point that everyone this side of Rudy Giuliani would acknowledge. Despite the Constitution’s categorical wording – it sweepingly authorizes the president to “grant Reprieves and Pardons for Offenses against the United States” – not everything goes. The pardon authority can’t be construed to allow a president to commit a crime or to violate constitutional principles in exercising it. He or she couldn’t decide, for instance, that only members of a particular racial group could be pardoned or begin selling reprieves to the highest bidder.
The pardon authority also doesn’t extend to self-pardon. The Department of Justice’s Office of Legal Counsel determined as much in 1974, when there was concern that President Richard Nixon might try to pardon himself during the Watergate scandal. The OLC concluded that self-pardon would violate a crucial principle of Anglo-American law embedded in the Constitution – namely, that nobody may be a judge in his own cause. If it were otherwise, presidents could place themselves above the law.
This principle clearly applies to a pardon of Trump’s own family as well. The contemplated pardon of Ivanka Trump, her husband, Jared Kushner, and Donald Trump Jr., whose fates are bound up in the family fortune, is at most, a slightly diluted version of the no-self-dealing principle that drove the legal counsel’s opinion in 1974.
