Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Pennsylvania families win $4.24M verdict against gas driller

Dimock Township, Pa., residents Nolen Scott Ely and his wife Monica Marta-Ely were awarded $ 2.75 million dollars by a federal jury on Thursday, March 10, 2016, at the William J. Nealon Federal Building and U.S. Courthouse in downtown Scranton, Pennsylvania, after finding Cabot Oil & Gas based in Houston, Texas responsible for contaminating their well water. Another Dimock Township couple Raymond and Victoria Hubert werw awarded $ 1.49 million dollars. Both families alleged that Cabot was negligent in drilling two natural gas wells near their Susquehanna County homes, which contained their wells with high levels of Methane. Both families have been pursuing the case for 6 years after rejecting a settlement offer in 2012.  ( Butch Comegys / The Times & Tribune via AP)   MANDATORY CREDIT
Dimock Township, Pa., residents Nolen Scott Ely and his wife Monica Marta-Ely were awarded $ 2.75 million dollars by a federal jury on Thursday, March 10, 2016, at the William J. Nealon Federal Building and U.S. Courthouse in downtown Scranton, Pennsylvania, after finding Cabot Oil & Gas based in Houston, Texas responsible for contaminating their well water. Another Dimock Township couple Raymond and Victoria Hubert werw awarded $ 1.49 million dollars. Both families alleged that Cabot was negligent in drilling two natural gas wells near their Susquehanna County homes, which contained their wells with high levels of Methane. Both families have been pursuing the case for 6 years after rejecting a settlement offer in 2012. ( Butch Comegys / The Times & Tribune via AP) MANDATORY CREDIT

Two couples were awarded nearly $4.25 million on Thursday after a federal jury found one of the largest natural gas producers in Pennsylvania was responsible for the contamination of their well water, capping a six-year odyssey that turned their sleepy village into a battleground over the nation’s shale drilling and hydraulic fracturing boom.

The verdict in Scranton came at the end of a bitter lawsuit pitting homeowners in Dimock against Houston-based Cabot Oil & Gas Corp. The company, a prolific driller in Pennsylvania’s Marcellus Shale formation, said it will appeal, accusing the jury of ignoring “overwhelming scientific and factual evidence that Cabot acted as a prudent operator in conducting its operations.”

Dimock was the scene of the most highly publicized case of methane contamination to emerge from the early days of Pennsylvania’s natural-gas drilling boom. State regulators blamed faulty gas wells drilled by Cabot for leaking combustible methane into Dimock’s groundwater. Cabot claimed the methane was naturally occurring and said the problems in the water wells predated Cabot’s arrival.

Dozens of plaintiffs settled with Cabot in 2012, but two families opted to take their claims to trial.

“They did something wrong. That was the whole point of getting it into the courtroom,” one of the plaintiffs, Scott Ely, told reporters outside the courthouse.