Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Jury weighs Myles Stout’s fate in shooting death

chattano-jury-weighs-stouts-fate-in-shooting-death
chattano-jury-weighs-stouts-fate-in-shooting-death
photo Myles Stout

An hour after midnight on March 9, 2011, the 20-year-old was alone in the interrogation room at the Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office, his head against the wall, sobbing “I’m sorry” to his mother, father, God and the young man who died from the bullet he triggered.

“I’m a [expletive] murderer,” Myles Stout cried.

Later, as he sunk to the floor, Stout continued to apologize to 18-year-old Myles Compton, who died almost immediately after Stout shot him in the chest that night at a friend’s home, with that friend’s father’s gun, which several people had been handling.

“It was an accident,” he says on a recording made by the sheriff’s office. “I love you Myles, you know I wouldn’t do it. … It wasn’t loaded.”

The question Stout weighed aloud that night — whether he is a murderer or a young man who committed a tragic fatal accident — is now in the hands of a Hamilton County jury after attorneys made their closing arguments Monday.