Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Rule of law prevails in Israel

Israel began late last week to reroute an especially controversial portion of its security barrier in the West Bank in order to comply with an Israeli Supreme Court ruling that the fence improperly separated Palestinian farmers from their land. The start of the work was justly celebrated by many residents of Bilin, who had protested weekly for five years that the barrier unfairly cut access to their property and livelihoods.

Not everyone in the village and surrounding area joined in the celebratory mood. While they they acknowledged the importance of the work begun to reroute the fence and to provide access to farmland, they noted that it was but a small victory in what remains a broad conflict. The larger, more important, victory, they said, will come when the entire wall is dismantled. That’s unlikely to happen.

While the court ruled in the Bilin case that it was not “convinced that it is necessary for security-military reasons to retain the current route that passes on Bilin’s lands,” construction of the rerouted wall there and elsewhere continues. When complete the barrier is expected to be a 430-mile long route of high cement slabs, electronic fencing, trenches and patrol roads.

In many places, the wall marches across relatively desolate territory. In others, however, it can encroach on private property or, like in Bilin, separate residents from long-held and desirable agricultural, commercial and industrial properties. Elsewhere, the wall forces Palestinians to travel miles out of heir way to reach work or vital services. It hardly is a surprise, then, that the security barrier has prompted sharp debate within Israel since its construction began in 2002.

Palestinians have never accepted the barrier. Many, but not all Israelis, view the barrier as a necessity. They argue, with some correctness, that the number of attempted suicide bombings and other acts of violence in Israel has declined in areas where the barrier is complete. Others within Israel argue with equal vehemence that the barrier might be necessary in some instances, but that if it is, it can be built in a manner that does not arbitrarily disrupt the everyday life of those who must live in proximity to it. There is, of course, no way to reconcile those conflicting options.