GREENVILLE, S.C. (AP) – Brianna Watts and Rachel Duncan hoped that this time it would be different – this time the clerk behind the counter wouldn’t say no.
Three months ago, the Greenville, South Carolina, couple had gone to the probate judge’s office with paperwork in hand, knowing there was no way the clerk would accept their application for a marriage license because of the state’s ban on same-sex marriage. But Wednesday was different.
The decision by the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday not to hear any appeals from states seeking to keep their gay marriage bans had given hope to Watts and Duncan – and thousands of couples across the country – that they would soon be able to marry.
But the courts inaction also triggered confusion in many states. Take some of those covered by the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. In Virginia, where the circuit court had previously overturned the ban, marriages have already started. In North Carolina, where the ban had been overturned by a lower court judge and the attorney general had promised not to defend it anymore, couples were expecting an imminent court decision to let them marry. In South Carolina, which had not yet had its law overturned and where the attorney general vowed to keep fighting for it, couples weren’t quite sure what would happen.
Despite the uncertainty, Duncan and Watts remained hopeful. Watts put on a turquoise dress with a white sweater. Duncan’s blue sweater covered her gray and white button down shirt. They wanted to look good for their “wedding day,” Duncan said.
