Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Why insurance denies your claim, but pays your neighbor’s

In this Thursday, Sept. 1, 2016, photo, Caiti Riley, who lost her left leg when she was 4-years-old, poses for a photo near her home in San Antonio. Riley's insurance plan is paying most of the cost for a new running leg to complement the one she uses every day. (AP Photo/Eric Gay)
In this Thursday, Sept. 1, 2016, photo, Caiti Riley, who lost her left leg when she was 4-years-old, poses for a photo near her home in San Antonio. Riley's insurance plan is paying most of the cost for a new running leg to complement the one she uses every day. (AP Photo/Eric Gay)

Tracey Stahl lost part of a leg to bone cancer last fall, and she has to wince through bouts of crippling pain from an ill-fitting artificial limb because of a strange health insurance limit: Her plan covers just one limb per lifetime.

She now has to weigh whether to dump the nearly $9,000 cost of a new leg on her credit card as she fights her insurance company over the restriction. “I feel – it’s embarrassing to say – paralyzed about what to do,” said Stahl, from her home in Penfield, New York.

Caiti Riley’s left leg was amputated below the knee at age 4 due to a rare birth defect. The San Antonio resident is 31 now and covered by the best insurance she’s ever had. Her plan is paying most of the roughly $5,000 bill for a new running leg to complement the one she uses every day.

“I work out every day, there’s nothing really that I can’t do now,” she said.

Glaring differences in insurance coverage persist for amputees, children with autism and others in need of certain expensive treatments even after the Affordable Care Act set new standards as part of its push to expand and improve coverage, and despite efforts by states to mandate coverage for some treatments.