The best argument for an amendment making it plain that the Tennessee Constitution forbids an income tax is the all-over-the-board arguments of the amendment’s foes.
A general income tax “is clearly banned under the state constitution” already, says House Democratic Caucus Chairman Mike Turner of Nashville. He dismisses as a “political ploy” a constitutional amendment that would make the ban explicit.
Yet some lawmakers who oppose the amendment don’t buy the view that an income tax is currently prohibited.
“I think we should leave future governors free to make those proposals,” said Rep. Mike Stewart, another Nashville Democrat.
Oh, and don’t forget a previous attorney general’s claim that an income tax is constitutional — nor the attempts to impose one despite court rulings against it.