Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Used luxury or fully-loaded new car? Edmunds weighs both

FILE - In this March 28, 2019, file photo a car shopper looks over a BMW X2 at the auto show in Denver. While the purchase of a new luxury vehicle is out of reach for many shoppers, buying a used 3-year-old version could be an intriguing option compared to buying a fully loaded non-luxury new vehicle for a similar price. (AP Photo/David Zalubowski, File)
FILE - In this March 28, 2019, file photo a car shopper looks over a BMW X2 at the auto show in Denver. While the purchase of a new luxury vehicle is out of reach for many shoppers, buying a used 3-year-old version could be an intriguing option compared to buying a fully loaded non-luxury new vehicle for a similar price. (AP Photo/David Zalubowski, File)

The luxury vehicle of your dreams might now be something you can afford, thanks to a record high number of lease returns hitting the used-car market. This trend has widened the price difference between a new vehicle and a 3-year-old used one, according to Edmunds transaction data.

Consider this scenario: You’re prepared to spend $30,000 on your next car. You’ve been looking into a 2019 Honda CR-V, which is an Edmunds top-ranked small SUV. For that price you can get the EX-L version that comes loaded with such options as leather, navigation, automatic climate control, and a rearview camera.

But if you looked to the used market, you could potentially get a 2016 Mercedes-Benz GLC, an Edmunds top-ranked luxury SUV. We found a midsize certified pre-owned GLC with just over 15,000 miles for about the same price as the new CR-V. It, too, had plenty of features including a panoramic sunroof, blind-spot assist and heated seats.

Mercedes luxury at a Honda price point ? it’s a tempting proposition. But is it the smarter choice? Edmunds looks at the pros and cons of buying a new non-luxury car versus a used luxury vehicle.

PROS: NEW NON-LUXURY VEHICLE