After last week’s appointment of Rob Philyaw as the next Juvenile Court judge, one Hamilton County commissioner is crying foul.
On April 11, commissioners appointed Philyaw over two other finalists – current Juvenile Magistrate Troy McDougal and attorney Curtis Bowe – to replace Suzanne Bailey, who is retiring.
Chairman Larry Henry had predicted a lengthy process, but Philyaw was appointed after one round of votes.
Greg Beck, one of three commissioners who supported Bowe, said the ease with which Philyaw was appointed was a telltale sign that he was the political favorite.
In February, early in the selection process, Beck and other commissioners expressed support for diversity on the bench. Then, Beck said whoever was selected should “understand that population and the demographics” served by the court.
