Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Chattanooga brokers plead guilty in scheme that bilked $5 million from hundreds of investors

Doug Dyer
Doug Dyer

Mickey McCamish didn’t know what to think when he saw the business card left by an FBI agent at his Heritage Landing home last spring.

“My wife immediately asked me what I had done,” McCamish recalled with a laugh Friday.

The retired Navy captain was not the subject of the FBI probe. But nearly $100,000 of investments he and family members made with a pair of Chattanooga financial brokers were part of an investigation that led to guilty pleas in a financial fraud that cost investors millions of dollars.

Since 2008, Douglas A. Dyer, 57, and James Hugh Brennan III, 67, raised more than $5 million from McCamish and hundreds of other investors for their Broad Street Venture. They told local friends and members of the UTC Quarterback Club, which Dyer once headed, they would invest the money in buying companies to take public or sell later for big gains.

photo Doug Dyer

But most of the promised investments were never made and the investors were swindled, according to the FBI and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.