Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Takeout: Simple shines in Out of the Blue chicken salad

simple-shines-in-out-of-the-blue-chicken-salad
simple-shines-in-out-of-the-blue-chicken-salad
photo The recipe for chicken salad at Out of the Blue is a well-kept secret. It is also one of the best chicken salads in town.

I’ve always been more of a tuna-salad guy than chicken-salad guy. Whether it’s scooped on a pile of lettuce or served sandwich style, I usually opt for tuna when given the choice.

However, whenever the opportunity to get the chicken salad from Out of the Blue presents itself, I grab it.

As with the best tuna salad, simple is better for me. I’m not a fan of big infusions of grapes, walnuts, celery or onion — and too much mayonnaise can ruin chicken. I don’t want a lot of ingredients competing, and owner Peggy Roselle has found the right formula.

Her chicken-salad recipe is different than most because of the curry flavoring she uses. The spice is not overpowering for me and adds a little something extra; as do the water chestnuts, which give it a nice crunch. I’ve had it both on a wheat roll (my favorite) and served on a bed of baby lettuce, which is how I got my takeout plate this week. My salad came with a small side of mixed fruit (cantaloupe and grapes) and a slice of bread.

It is a relatively simple yet refreshing and tasty meal.